CHAP. IV.
J
CHRISTIAN RELIGION. b75
cmitant. Others, perceiving this to be too unlimited a 1/cense,
have mentioned two keys, discretion and power. Others, again
observing that the wickedness of the priests was restrained by
such moderation, have invented other keys, an authority of
discerning which they might use in pronouncing decisions;
and a power, which they might exert in execnting their sen-
tences ; with knowledge, to assist as a counsellor. But they
venture not to explain this binding and loosing simply to mean,
forgiving and obliterating sins ; because they hear the Lord
proclaiming by the prophet, " I am the Lord, and beside me
there is no Saviour. I, even I, am he which blotteth ont thy
transgressions." (q) But they say, that it belongs to the priest
to pronounce who are bouiid^ or loosed, and to declare whose
sins are remitted or retained ; and that he declares it, either by
confession, when he absolves and retains sins ; or by his sen-
tence, when he excommunicates, and when he receives to the
communion of the sacraments. Lastly, when they perceive
that they are not yet extricated from this difficulty, but that it
may always be objected, that their priests frequently bind and
loose imin'oper persons, who are not therefore bound or loosed
in heaven,— as their last resource, they reply, that the commis-
sion of the keys must be understood with some limitation,
Christ having promised, that the sentence of the priest, which
has been justly delivered, according to the merits of the per-
sons bound or loosed, shall be confirmed at his tribunal. They
add also, that these keys were given by Christ to all priests,
who receive them from the bishops on their promotion to the
sacerdotal office ; but that the free use of them belongs only
to those who exercise ecclesiastical functions ; that the keys
themselves remain, indeed, with the excommunicated or sus-
pended ones, but that they are rusty and disused. And those
who advance these things may justly be considered modest
and sober, in comparison with others, who, on a new anvil,
have fabricated new keys, with which they tell us the trea-
sure of the Church is locked up ; which we shall examine in
the proper place.
XVL I shall briefly reply to each of these things ; though
without noticing, at present, the justice or injustice with
which they bind the souls of the faithful by their laws ; as
that will be considered in due order. But when they impose
a law respecting the enumeration of all sins ; when they deny
'hat sin is forgiven, but on condition that a firm resolution has
been formed to confess it ; when they say that there remains
no e.'itrance into Paradise, if the opportunity of confession has
been neglected,— this is altogether intolerable. Must al. «r s
(q) Isaiah xliii. 11, 35.