of Europe. It was originally given to all presbyters, as implied in their name of elders, and
was a title of humility when it became peculiar to the bishops, as (1 Pet. v. 3) non Domini
sed patres. St. Paul (1 Cor. iv. 15) shows that “in Christ”—that is, under Him—we may have
such “fathers;” and thus, while he indicates the true sense of the precept, he leads us to re-
cognise a prophetic force and admonition in our Saviour’s words (Matt. xxiii.), “Call no man
your father upon the earth.” Thus interpreted, these words seem to be a warning against
the sense to which this name, Papa, became, long afterwards, restricted, in Western Europe:
Notre St. Père, le Pape, as they say in France. This was done by the decree of the ambitious
Hildebrand, Gregory VII. (who died a.d. 1085), when, in a synod held at Rome, he defined
that “the title Pope should be peculiar to one only in the Christian world.” The Easterns, of
course, never paid any respect to this novelty and dictation, and to this day their patriarchs
are popes; and not only so, for the parish priests of the Greek churches are called by the
same name. I was once cordially invited to take a repast “with the pope,” on visiting a Greek
church on the shores of the Adriatic. It is said, however, that a distinction is made between
the words πάπας and παπᾶς; the latter being peculiar to inferiors, according to the refinements
of Goar, a Western critic. Valeat quantum. But I must here note, that as “words are things,”
and as infinite damage has been done to history and to Christian truth by tolerating this
empiricism of Rome, I have restored scientific accuracy, in this series, whenever reference
is made to the primitive bishops of Rome, who were no more “Popes” than Cincinnatus
was an emperor. It is time that theological science should accept, like other sciences, the
language of truth and the terminology of demonstrated fact. The early bishops of Rome
155
were geographically important, and were honoured as sitting in the only apostolic see of
the West; but they were almost inconsiderable in the structural work of the ante-Nicene
ages, and have left no appreciable impress on its theology. After the Council of Nice they
were recognised as patriarchs, though equals among brethren, and nothing more. The am-
bition of Boniface III. led him to name himself “universal bishop.” This was at first a mere
name “of intolerable pride,” as his predecessor Gregory had called it, but Nicholas I. (a.d.
858) tried to make it real, and, by means of the false decretals, created himself the first “Pope”
in the modern sense, imposing his despotism on the West, and identifying it with the polity
of Western churches, which alone submitted to it. Thus, it was never Catholic, and came
into existence only by nullifying the Nicene Constitutions, and breaking away from Catholic
communion with the parent churches of the East. Compare Casaubon (Exercit., xiv. p. 280,
etc.) in his comments on Baronius. I have thus stated with scientific precision what all candid
critics and historians, even the Gallicans included, enable us to prove. Why, then, keep up
the language of fiction and imposture,1110 so confusing to young students? I believe the
1110 Pompey and others were called imperatores before the Cæsars, but who includes them with the Roman
emperors?
395
Elucidations.