even in those cases to which instinct extends, it mixes its influence with the natural principle,
and guides and regulates its operations. And when this is the case, the pity which is exercised,
may be called a virtuous compassion. So there is a virtuous gratitude; or a gratitude that
arises not only from self-love, but from a superior principle of disinterested general bene-
volence. As, when we receive kindness from such as we love already, we are more disposed
to gratitude, and disposed to greater degrees of it, than when the mind is destitute of any
such friendly prepossession. Therefore, when the superior principle of virtuous love has a
governing hand, and regulates the affair, it may be called a virtuous gratitude. There is also
a virtuous love of justice, arising from pure benevolence to being in general; as that naturally
and necessarily inclines the heart, that every particular being should have such a share of
benevolence as is proportioned to its dignity, consisting in the degree of its being, and the
degree of its virtue. And thus it is easy to see, how there may be a virtuous sense of desert
different from what is natural and common; and a virtuous conscientiousness, or a sanctified
conscience. And as, when natural affections have their operations mixed with the influence
of virtuous benevolence, and are directed and determinedthereby, they may be called virtuous;
so there may be a virtuous love of parents to children, and between other near relatives; a
virtuous love of our town, or country, or nation. Yea, and a virtuous love between the sexes,
as there may be the influence of virtue mingled with instinct; and virtue may govern with
regard to the particular manner of its operation, and may guide it to such ends as are
agreeable to the great purposes of true virtue.
Genuine virtue prevents that increase of the habits of pride and sensuality, which tend
to diminish the exercises of the useful and necessary principles of nature. And a principle
of general benevolence softens and sweetens the mind, makes it more susceptible of the
proper influence of the gentler natural instincts, directs every one into its proper channel,
determines the exercise to the proper manner and measure, and guides all to the best pur-
140
poses. 231
231 In this chapter our very ingenious and judicious author has assigned several reasons why many things
are commonly thought to be virtuous which in reality are not so, or have no claim to moral goodness in the
proper acceptation of these words. It is with some reluctance that we notice in this place a writer, who by his
masterly attack on modern infidelity and atheism, has rendered such important service to the cause of truth and
virtue: but who seems either to have been dissatisfied with these reasons, or to have omitted a strict examination
of them when duty required it. We shall not here inquire into the candour of Mr. Robert Hall’s remarks, in as-
sociating President Edwards with modern infidels on the subject of virtue: nor on the congruity of the business,
whereby a definition implying, and an explication declaring, the love of God to be essential to true virtue, is
made to coincide with a definition adopted by infidels, and consistent with atheism itself. These are his words:
913
CHAPTER VII. The reasons of many mistakes