CHAP. XVIII. CHHISTIAN RELIGION. 271
the cause of hardening it ; as if the two things did not per
fectly agree with each other, though in different senses, viz.,
that man, though acted upon by God, at the same time also
acts. But I retort the objection on those who make it. If
to harden means only bare permission, the contumacy will
not properly belong to Pharaoh. Now, could any thing be
more feeble and insipid than to interpret as if Pharaoh had
only allowed himself to be hardened? We may add, that
Scripture cuts off all handle for such cavils : " I," saith the
Lord, "will harden his heart," (Exod. iv. 21.) So also,
Moses says of the inhabitants of the land of Canaan, that
they went forth to battle because the Lord had hardened
their hearts, (Josh. xi. 20.) The same thing is repeated by
another prophet, " He turned their hearts to hate his people," (Psalm cv. 25.) In like manner, in Isaiah, he says of the
Assyrian, " I will send him against a hypocritical nation, and
against the people of my wrath wTill I give him a charge to
take the spoil, and to take the prey," (Isaiah x. 6 ;) not that he intends to teach wicked and obstinate man to obey spon
taneously, but because he bends them to execute his judgments,
just as if they carried their orders engraven on their minds.
And hence it appears that they are impelled by the sure
appointment of God. I admit, indeed, that God often acts
in the reprobate by interposing the agency of Satan ; but in
such a manner, that Satan himself performs his part, just as
he is impelled, and succeeds only in so far as he is permitted.
The evil spirit that troubled Saul is said to be from the Lord,
(1 Sain. xvi. 14,) to intimate that Saul's madness was a just punishment from God. Satan is also said to blind the minds
of those who believe not, (2 Cor. iv. 4.) But how so, unless
that a spirit of error is sent from God himself, making those
who refuse to obey the truth to believe a lie ? According to
the former view, it is said, " If the prophet be deceived
when he hath spoken a thing, I the Lord have deceived that
prophet," (Ezek. xiv. 9.) According to the latter view, he
is said to have given men over to a reprobate mind, (Rom.
i. 28,) because he is the special author of his own just ven
geance; wrhereas Satan is only his minister, (see Calv. in
Ps. cxli. 4.) But as in the Second Book, (Chap. iv. sec. 3, 4,)