Chapter VII.—The Alleged Discrepancy in the Gospels in regard to the Genealogy of
Christ.
1. Matthew and Luke in their gospels have given us the genealogy of Christ differently,
and many suppose that they are at variance with one another. Since as a consequence every
believer, in ignorance of the truth, has been zealous to invent some explanation which shall
harmonize the two passages, permit us to subjoin the account of the matter which has come
down to us,107 and which is given by Africanus, who was mentioned by us just above, in
his epistle to Aristides,108 where he discusses the harmony of the gospel genealogies. After
refuting the opinions of others as forced and deceptive, he give the account which he had
received from tradition109 in these words:
107 “Over against the various opinions of uninstructed apologists for the Gospel history, Eusebius introduces
this account of Africanus with the words, τὴν περὶ τούτων κατελθούσαν εὶς ἡμᾶς ἱστορίαν.” (Spitta.)
108 On Africanus, see Bk. VI. chap. 31. Of this Aristides to whom the epistle is addressed we know nothing.
He must not be confounded with the apologist Aristides, who lived in the reign of Trajan (see below, Bk. IV. c.
3). Photius (Bibl. 34) mentions this epistle, but tells us nothing about Aristides himself. The epistle exists in
numerous fragments, from which Spitta (Der Brief des Julius Africanus an Aristides kritisch untersucht und
hergestellt, Halle, 1877) attempts to reconstruct the original epistle. His work is the best and most complete upon
the subject. Compare Routh, Rel. Sacræ, II. pp. 228–237 and pp. 329–356, where two fragments are given and
discussed at length. The epistle (as given by Mai) is translated in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, Am. ed. VI. p. 125 ff.
The attempt of Africanus is, so far as we know, the first critical attempt to harmonize the two genealogies of
Christ. The question had been the subject merely of guesses and suppositions until his time. He approaches the
matter in a free critical spirit (such as seems always to have characterized him), and his investigations therefore
deserve attention. He holds that both genealogies are those of Joseph, and this was the unanimous opinion of
antiquity, though, as he says, the discrepancies were reconciled in various ways. Africanus himself, as will be
seen, explains by the law of Levirate marriages, and his view is advocated by Mill (On the Mythical Interpretation
of the Gospel, p. 201 sq.); but of this interpretation Rev. John Lightfoot justly says, “There is neither reason for
it, nor, indeed, any foundation at all.” Upon the supposition that both genealogies relate to Joseph the best ex-
planation is that Matthew’s table represents the royal line of legal successors to the throne of David, while Luke’s
gives the line of actual descent. This view is ably advocated by Hervey in Smith’s Bible Dictionary (article
Genealogy of Jesus). Another opinion which has prevailed widely since the Reformation is that Luke gives the
genealogy of Mary. The view is defended very ingeniously by Weiss (Leben Jesu, I. 205, 2d edition). For further
particulars see, besides the works already mentioned, the various commentaries upon Matthew and Luke and
the various lives of Christ, especially Andrews’, p. 55 sq.
109 Eusebius makes a mistake in saying that Africanus had received the explanation which follows from tra-
dition. For Africanus himself says expressly (§15, below) that his interpretation is not supported by testimony.
Eusebius’ error has been repeated by most writers upon the subject, but is exposed by Spitta, ibid. p. 63.
The Alleged Discrepancy in the Gospels in regard to the Genealogy of Christ.
133
The Alleged Discrepancy in the Gospels in regard to the Genealogy of Ch…