Book XXIX.
Faustus seeks to justify the docetism of the Manichæans. Augustin insists that there is
nothing disgraceful in being born.
1. Faustus said: If Christ was visible, and suffered without having been born, this was
sorcery. This argument of yours may be turned against you, by replying that it was sorcery
if He was conceived or brought forth without being begotten. It is not in accordance with
the law of nature that a virgin should bring forth, and still less that she should still be a virgin
after bringing forth. Why, then, do you refuse to admit that Christ, in a preternatural
manner, suffered without submitting to the condition of birth? Believe me: in substance,
both our beliefs are contrary to nature; but our belief is decent, and yours is not. We give
an explanation of Christ’s passion which is at least probable, while the only explanation you
give of His birth is false. In fine, we hold that He suffered in appearance, and did not really
die; you believe in an actual birth, and conception in the womb. If it is not so, you have
only to acknowledge that the birth too was a delusion, and our whole dispute will be at an
end. As to what you frequently allege, that Christ could not have appeared or spoken to
men without having been born, it is absurd; for, as our teachers have shown, angels have
often appeared and spoken to men.
2. Augustin replied: We do not say that to die without having been born is sorcery;
for, as we have said already, this happened in the case of Adam. But, though it had never
happened, who will venture to say that Christ could not, if He had so pleased, have come
327
without taking His body from a virgin, and yet appearing in a true body to redeem us by a
true death? However, it was better that He should be, as He actually was, born of a virgin,
and, by His condescension, do honor to both sexes, for whose deliverance He was to die,
by taking a man’s body born of a woman. In this He testifies emphatically against you, and
refutes your doctrine, which makes the sexes the work of the devil. What we call sorcery in
your doctrine is your making Christ’s passion and death to have been only in appearance,
so that, by a spectral illusion, He seemed to die when He did not. Hence you must also
make His resurrection spectral and illusory and false; for if there was no true death, there
could not be a real resurrection. Hence also the marks which He showed to His doubting
disciples must have been false; and Thomas was not assured by truth, but cheated by a lie,
when he exclaimed, "My Lord, and my God."1012 And yet you would have us believe that
your tongue utters truth, though Christ’s whole body was a falsehood. Our argument against
you is, that the Christ you make is such that you cannot be His true disciples unless you too
practise deceit. The fact that Christ’s body was the only one born of a virgin does not prove
that there was sorcery in His birth, any more than there is sorcery in its being the only body
to rise again on the third day, never to die any more. Will you say that there was sorcery in
1012 John xx. 28.
Faustus seeks to justify the docetism of the Manichæans. Augustin insists that there is nothing disgraceful in being born.
557
Faustus seeks to justify the docetism of the Manichæans. Augustin insists…