the Father. For just as the Father is not good because He wills to be so, or is compelled to
be so, but is above these conditions—is good, that is, by nature,—even so the putting forth
of His generative power is neither of will nor of necessity.
105. Yet let us grant their proposal. Granted that the Generation depends on the Will
of Him Who generates; when do they say that this act of will took place? If it was in the be-
ginning, then, plainly, the Son was in the beginning. If the Will is eternal, then the Son also
is eternal. If the Will began to exist, then God the Father, as He was, was so displeased with
Himself, that He made a change in His condition, that is to say, without His Son He was
displeasing to Himself; in His Son He began to be well pleased.
106. To follow out the consequences thereof. If the Father conceived, after the manner
of human nature, a desire to beget, then did He also pass through all the experiences which
befal men before the birth takes place—but we find that generation is not determined merely
by will, but is an object of wish.
107. Thus do they betray their own ungodliness, who would have it that Christ’s gener-
ation had a beginning, in order that it may seem, not that true begetting of the Word abiding,
but the utterance of words that pass and are forgotten, and that by intrusion of [the premiss
of] a multitude of sons, they may [be warranted to] deny Christ’s personal possession of the
divine attributes, to the end that He may be regarded as neither the only-begotten nor the
first-begotten Son; and lastly, that given the belief that His existence had a beginning, it may
also be deemed as appointed to have an end.
108. But neither had the Son of God any beginning, seeing that He already was at the
beginning, nor shall He come to an end, Who is the Beginning and the End of the Uni-
verse;1646 for being the Beginning, how could He take and receive that which He already
had,1647 or how shall He come to an end, being Himself the End of all things, so that in that
End we have an abiding-place without end? The Divine Generation is not an event occurring
in the course of time, and within its limits, and therefore before it time is not, and in it time
has no place.
109. Again, their aimless and futile question finds no loophole for entry, even when
directed upon the creation itself;1648 nay, indeed, temporal existences appear, in certain
cases, to admit of no division of time. For instance, light generates radiance, but we can
neither conceive that the radiance begins to exist after the light, nor that the light is in exist-
1646 Rev. i. 8, 17; ii. 8; iii. 14; xxii. 13; Isa. xli. 4; xliv. 6; xlviii. 12.
1647 “And,” we may add; “already was.”—St. Ambrose refers to St. John viii. 25, but the reference is only
justifiable by means of a defective rendering of the Greek; unless we suppose our Saviour to be alluding to what
the prophets had said of Himself as well as to His own statements. Cf. Bk. III. vii. 49.
1648 On the analogy of which, indeed, Arianism endeavoured to conceive of the Nature and Activities of
God.
614
Chapter IX. Various quibbling arguments, advanced by the Arians to show…