Book V.
Faustus claims that the Manichæans and not the Catholics are consistent believers in
the Gospel, and seeks to establish this claim by comparing Manichæan and Catholic obedi-
ence to the precepts of the Gospel. Augustin exposes the hypocrisy of the Manichæans and
praises the asceticism of Catholics.
1. Faustus said: Do I believe the gospel? You ask me if I believe it, though my obedience
to its commands shows that I do. I should rather ask you if you believe it, since you give
no proof of your belief. I have left my father, mother, wife, and children, and all else that
the gospel requires;320 and do you ask if I believe the gospel? Perhaps you do not know
what is called the gospel. The gospel is nothing else than the preaching and the precept of
Christ. I have parted with all gold and silver, and have left off carrying money in my purse;
content with daily food; without anxiety for tomorrow; and without solicitude about how
I shall be fed, or where-withal I shall be clothed: and do you ask if I believe the gospel? You
see in me the blessings of the gospel; 321 and do you ask if I believe the gospel? You see me
poor, meek, a peacemaker, pure in heart, mourning, hungering, thirsting, bearing persecu-
tions and enmity for righteousness’ sake; and do you doubt my belief in the gospel? One
can understand now how John the Baptist, after seeing Jesus, and also hearing of His works,
yet asked whether He was Christ. Jesus properly and justly did not deign to reply that He
was; but reminded him of the works of which he had already heard: "The blind see, the deaf
163
hear, the dead are raised."322 In the same way, I might very well reply to your question
whether I believe the gospel, by saying, I have left all, father, mother, wife, children, gold,
silver, eating, drinking, luxuries, pleasures; take this as a sufficient answer to your questions,
and believe that you will be blessed if you are not offended in me.323
2. But, according to you, to believe the gospel is not only to obey its commands, but
also to believe in all that is written in it; and, first of all, that God was born. But neither is
believing the gospel only to believe that Jesus was born, but also to do what He commands.
So, if you say that I do not believe the gospel because I disbelieve the incarnation, much
more do you not believe because you disregard the commandments. At any rate, we are on
a par till these questions are settled. If your disregard of the precepts does not prevent you
from professing faith in the gospel, why should my rejection of the genealogy prevent me?
And if, as you say, to believe the gospel includes both faith in the genealogies and obedience
to the precepts, why do you condemn me, since we both are imperfect? What one wants
320 Matt. xix. 29.
321 Matt. v. 3-11.
322 Matt. xi. 2-6.
323 [This is a good description of ideal Manichæan religious life. Whether Faustus lived up to the claims
here set forth is another question.—A.H.N.]
Faustus claims that the Manichæans and not the Catholics are consistent believers in the Gospel, and seeks to establish this claim by comparing Manichæan and Catholic obedience to the precepts of the Gospel. Augustin exposes the hypocrisy of the Manichæans and praises the asceticism of Catholics.
276
Faustus claims that the Manichæans and not the Catholics are consistent…