is not freed yet from fleshly feeling),—in such details of the story (she continued) I think
our Lord teaches us this; that those still living in the flesh must as much as ever they can
separate and free themselves in a way from its attachments by virtuous conduct, in order
that after death they may not need a second death to cleanse them from the remnants that
are owing to this cement1829 of the flesh, and, when once the bonds are loosed from around
the soul, her soaring1830 up to the Good may be swift and unimpeded, with no anguish of
the body to distract her. For if any one becomes wholly and thoroughly carnal in thought,
such an one, with every motion and energy of the soul absorbed in fleshly desires, is not
parted from such attachments, even in the disembodied state; just as those who have lingered
long in noisome places do not part with the unpleasantness contracted by that lengthened
stay, even when they pass into a sweet atmosphere. So1831 it is that, when the change is made
into the impalpable Unseen, not even then will it be possible for the lovers of the flesh to
avoid dragging away with them under any circumstances some fleshly foulness; and thereby
their torment will be intensified, their soul having been materialized by such surroundings.
I think too that this view of the matter harmonizes to a certain extent with the assertion
made by some persons that around their graves shadowy phantoms of the departed are often
seen1832. If this is really so, an inordinate attachment of that particular soul to the life in the
flesh is proved to have existed, causing it to be unwilling, even when expelled from the flesh,
1829 κόλλης. The metaphor is Platonic. “The soul…absolutely bound and glued to the body” (Phædo, p. 82
E).
1830 her soaring. Plato first spoke (Phædrus, p. 248 C) of “that growth of wing, by which the soul is lifted.”
Once these natural wings can get expanded, her flight upwards is a matter of course. This image is reproduced
by Plotinus p. 769 A (end of Enneads); Libanius, Pro Socrate, p. 258; Synesius, De Providentiâ, p. 90 D, and
Hymn i. III, where he speaks of the ἅλμα κοῦφον of the soul, and Hymn iii. 42. But there is mixed here with the
idea of a flight upwards (i.e. ἀναδρομὴ), that of the running-ground as well (cf. Greg. De scopo Christian. III. p.
299, τοῖς τῆς ἀρετῆς δρόμοις), which, as sanctioned in the New Testament, Chrysostom so often uses.
1831 οὕτως answers to καθάπερ, not to ὡς above.
1832 shadowy phantoms of the departed are often seen. Cf. Origen c. Cels. ii. 60 (in answer to Celsus’ “Epicurean”
opinion that ghosts are pure illusion): “He who does believe this (i.e. in ghosts) necessarily believes in the im-
mortality, or at all events the long continuance of the soul: as Plato does in his treatise on the soul (i.e. the Phædo)
when he says that the shadowy apparitions of the dead hover round their tombs. These apparitions, then, have
some substance: it is the so-called ‘radiant’ frame in which the soul exists. But Celsus, not liking this, would have
us believe that people have waking dreams and ‘imagine as true, in accordance with their wishes, a wild piece
of unreality.’ In sleep we may well believe that this is the case: not so in waking hours, unless some one is quite
out of his senses, or is melancholy mad.” But Origen here quotes Plato in connection with the reality of the Re-
surrection body of Christ: Gregory refers to ghosts only, with regard to the φιλοσώματοι, whose whole condition
after death he represents very much in Plato’s words. See Phædo, p. 81 B.
833
On the Soul and the Resurrection.