be administered by an unrighteous man, and that no unrighteous baptism, but such as is
just and true,—not because it belongs to the unrighteous man, but because it is of God.
And herein I am uttering no calumny against you, as you never cease to do, on some pretense
or other, against the whole world; and, what is even more intolerable, you do not even bring
any proof about the very points on which you found your calumnies. But I know not how
this can possibly be endured, because you not only bring calumnies against holy men about
unrighteous men, but you even bring a charge against the holy baptism itself, which must
needs be holy in any man, however unrighteous he may be, from a comparison with the
infection arising from the sins of wicked men, so that you say that baptism partakes of the
character of him by whom it is possessed, or administered, or received. Furthermore, if a
man partakes of the character of him in whose company he approaches sacred mysteries,
and if the sacraments themselves partake of the character of the men in whom they are, holy
men may well be satisfied to find consolation in the thought that they only fare like holy
551
baptism itself in hearing false accusations from your lips. But it would be well for you to
see how you are condemned out of your own mouths, if both the sober among you are
counted as drunken from the infection of the drunken in your ranks, and the merciful among
you become robbers from the infection of the robbers, and whatever evil is found among
you in the persons of wicked men is perforce shared by those who are not wicked; and if
baptism itself is unclean in all of you who are unclean, and if it is of different kinds according
to the varying character of uncleanness itself, as it must be if it is perforce of the same
character as the man by whom it is possessed or administered. These suppositions most
undoubtedly are false, and accordingly they in no wise injure us, when you bring them for-
ward against us without looking back upon yourselves. But they do injure you, because,
when you bring them forward falsely, they do not fall on us; but since you imagine them to
be true, they recoil upon yourselves.
1063
Chapter 33