real ground for these pretences and appearances. (3.) To those who, although they have not
saving grace, yet have that other sort of real godliness, or saintship, viz. moral sincerity in
religion; and so are properly a sort of real saints, true Christians, sincerely godly persons, and
disciples indeed, though they have no saving grace. And, (4.) To those who make a profession
and have a visibility of this latter sort of sincere Christianity, and are nominally such kinds
of saints, but are not so indeed.—So that here are two sorts of real Christians, and two sorts
of visible Christians; two sorts of invisible and real churches of Christ, and two sorts of visible
churches. Now will any one that is well acquainted with the New Testament say, there is in
that the least appearance or shadow of such a four-fold use of the words, saints, disciples,
&c.? It is manifest by what was observed before, that these words are there used but two
ways; and that those of mankind to whom these names are applied, are there distinguished
into but two sorts, viz. Those who have really a saving interest in Christ, spiritual conformity
and union to him, and those who have a name for it, as having a profession and appearance
of it. And this is further evident by various representations, which we there find of the visible
church; as in the company of virgins that went forth to meet the bridegroom, we find a dis-
tinction of them into but two sorts, viz. The wise that had both lamps and oil; and those who
had lamps indeed like the wise virgins, (therein having an external show of the same thing,)
but really had no oil; signifying that they had the same profession and outward show of re-
ligion, and entertained the same hopes with the wise virgins. So when the visible church is
represented by the husbandman’s floor, we find a distinction but of two sorts, viz. the wheat
and the chaff. And, when the church is compared to the husbandman’s field, we find a dis-
tinction but of two sorts, the wheat and the tares, which (naturalists observe) appear exactly
like the wheat, till it comes to bring forth its fruit; representing, that those who are only
visible Christians, have an appearance of the nature of wheat, which shall be gathered into
Christ’s barn, that is, of the nature of saving grace.
2. It is evident, that those who had the name of disciples in the times of the New Testa-
ment, bore the name with reference to a visibility of the same relation to Christ, which they
had who should be finally owned as his. This is manifest, John viii. 30, 31. “As he spake these
words, many believed on him. Then said Jesus to those Jews which believed on him, If ye
continue in my word, then are ye my disciples indeed.” (Compare Luke xiv. 25, 26, 27.. and
John xv. 8..) The phrase, disciples indeed, is relative; and has reference to a visibility, pretence,
or name, only, to which it is set in opposition; which makes it evident, that those who then
bore the name of disciples, had a visibility and pretence of discipleship indeed. For true dis-
cipleship is not properly set in opposition to any thing else but a pretence to the same thing,
that is not true. The phrase, gold indeed,is in opposition to something that has the appearance
of that same metal, and not to an appearance of brass. If there were another sort of real dis-
cipleship in those days, besides saving discipleship, persons might be Christ’s disciples indeed,
or truly, (as the word in the original is,) without continuing in his word, and without selling
1762
SECTION I. Church members should be visible saints.