that it was the second, if one is not willing to admit that it was the first that saw the Revelation,
which is ascribed by name to John.952
7. And Papias, of whom we are now speaking, confesses that he received the words of
172
the apostles from those that followed them, but says that he was himself a hearer of Aristion
and the presbyter John. At least he mentions them frequently by name, and gives their tra-
ditions in his writings. These things we hope, have not been uselessly adduced by us.
8. But it is fitting to subjoin to the words of Papias which have been quoted, other pas-
sages from his works in which he relates some other wonderful events which he claims to
have received from tradition.
9. That Philip the apostle dwelt at Hierapolis with his daughters has been already
stated.953 But it must be noted here that Papias, their contemporary, says that he heard a
prove that a church stood outside of the walls of Ephesus, on the spot where John was buried, and another inside
of the walls, on the site of the house in which he had resided, and that thus two spots were consecrated to the
memory of a single John. The proof which he brings in support of this may not lead many persons to adopt his
conclusions, and yet after reading his discussion of the matter one must admit that the existence of two memorials
in Ephesus, such as Dionysius, Eusebius, and Jerome refer to, by no means proves that more than one John was
buried there.
952 A similar suggestion had been already made by Dionysius in the passage quoted by Eusebius in Bk. VII.
chap. 25, and Eusebius was undoubtedly thinking of it when he wrote these words. The suggestion is a very
clever one, and yet it is only a guess, and does not pretend to be more. Dionysius concludes that the Apocalypse
must have been written by some person named John, because it testifies to that fact itself; but the style, and
other internal indications, lead him to think that it cannot have been written by the author of the fourth Gospel,
whom he assumes to be John the apostle. He is therefore led to suppose that the Apocalypse was written by some
other John. He does not pretend to say who that John was, but thinks it must have been some John that resided
in Asia; and he then adds that there were said to be two tombs in Ephesus bearing the name of John,—evidently
implying, though he does not say it, that he is inclined to think that this second John thus commemorated was
the author of the Apocalypse. It is plain from this that he had no tradition whatever in favor of this theory, that
it was solely an hypothesis arising from critical difficulties standing in the way of the ascription of the book to
the apostle John. Eusebius sees in this suggestion a very welcome solution of the difficulties with which he feels
the acceptance of the book to be beset, and at once states it as a possibility that this “presbyter John,” whom he
has discovered in the writings of Papias, may have been the author of the book. But the authenticity of the
Apocalypse was too firmly established to be shaken by such critical and theological difficulties as influenced
Dionysius, Eusebius, and a few others, and in consequence nothing came of the suggestion made here by Euse-
bius. In the present century, however, the “presbyter John” has again played an important part among some
critics as the possible author of certain of the Johannine writings, though the authenticity of the Apocalypse has
(until very recently) been so commonly accepted even by the most negative critics that the “presbyter John” has
not figured at all as the author of it; nor indeed is he likely to in the future.
953 In chap. 31, above. On the confusion of the evangelist with the apostle Philip, see that chapter, note 6.
373
The Writings of Papias.