adapt them also to the doctrine we hold:—“Let there be no questioning among sensible men
on this point, why He did not do so before”—for the word “before” has a temporal sense,
opposed to what is “afterwards” and “later”: but on the supposition that time does not exist,
the terms expressing temporal interval are surely abolished with it. Now the Lord was before
times and before ages: questioning as to “before” or “after” concerning the Maker of the
ages is useless in the eyes of reasonable men: for words of this class are devoid of all meaning,
if they are not used in reference to time. Since then the Lord is antecedent to times, the
words “before” and “after” have no place as applied to Him. This may perhaps be sufficient
to refute arguments that need no one to overthrow them, but fall by their own feebleness.
For who is there with so much leisure that he can give himself up to such an extent to listen
to the arguments on the other side, and to our contention against the silly stuff? Since,
however, in men prejudiced by impiety, deceit is like some ingrained dye, hard to wash out,
and deeply burned in upon their hearts, let us spend yet a little time upon our argument, if
haply we may be able to cleanse their souls from this evil stain. After the utterances that I
have quoted, and after adding to them, in the manner of his teacher Prunicus,912 some un-
connected and ill-arranged octads of insolence and abuse, he comes to the crowning point
of his arguments, and, leaving the illogical exposition of his folly, arms his discourse once
more with the weapons of dialectic, and maintains his absurdity against us, as he imagines,
syllogistically.
912 So in Book I. πρῶτον μὲν τῆς Προυνίκου σοφίας γίνεται μαθητὴς, and Book XIII. p. 844 (Paris Edit.). It
may be questioned whether the phrase in Books I. and XIII., and that here, refers to a supposed connection of
Eunomius with Gnosticism. The Προύνικος Σοφία of the Gnostics was a “male-female,” and hence the masculine
τὸν παιδεύτην might properly be applied to it. If this point were cleared up, we might be more certain of the
meaning to be attached to the word ὀκτάδας, which is also possibly borrowed from the Gnostic phraseology,
being akin to the form ὀγδοάδας. [On the Gnostic conception of “Prunicus,” see the note on the subject in
Harvey’s Irenæus (vol. I. p. 225), and Smith and Wace’s Dict. Chr. Biogr. s.v. On the Gnostic Ogdoads, see
Mansel’s Gnostic Heresies, pp. 152 sqq., 170 sqq., and the articles on Basilides and Valentinus in Dict. Chr. Biogr.]
410
He then ingeniously shows that the generation of the Son is not according…