334 JEROME.
him also read the pamphlets of Hilary on the
re-baptization of heretics which he published
against us, and he will there find Hilary him-
self confessing that 'Julius, Marcus, Sylvester, and the other bishops of old alike welcomed
all heretics to repentance ; and, further, to shew
that he could not justly claim possession of the
true custom ; the Council of Nicsea also, to
which we referred not long ago, welcomed all
heretics with the exception of9 the disciples of Paul of Samosata. And, what is more, it al-
lows a Novatian bishop on conversion to have
the rank of presbyter, 3 a decision which con- demns both Lucifer and Hilary, since the
same person who is ordained is also baptized.
28. I might spend the day in speaking to
the same effect, and dry up all the streams
of argument with the single Sun of the Church.
But as we have already had a long discussion
and the protracted controversy has wearied
out the attention of our audience, I will tell
you my opinion briefly and without reserve.
We ought to remain in that Church which was
founded by the Apostles and continues to this
day. If ever you hear of any that are called
Christians taking their name not from the
Lord Jesus Christ, but from some other, for
instance, Marcionites, Valentinians, Men of
' Bishops of Rome— Julius 337-352 ; Mark Jan. i8-Oct. 7, 336;
Sylvester 314-335. 3 Canon 19.
3 Canon 8. The bishop might give him the nominal honour of a bishop.
the mountain or the plain,1 you may be sure that you have there not the Church of Christ,
but the synagogue of Antichrist. For the
fact that they took their rise after the founda-
tion of the Church is proof that they are those
whose coming the Apostle foretold. And let
them not flatter themselves if they think they
have Scripture authority for their assertions,
since the devil himself quoted Scripture, and
the essence of the Scriptures is not the letter,
but the meaning. Otherwise, if we follow the
letter, we too can concoct a new dogma and
assert that such persons as wear shoes and
have two coats must not be received into the
Church.
L. You must not suppose that victory rests
with you only. We are both conquerors, and
each of us carries off the palm, — you are vic-
torious over me, and I over my error. May I
always when I argue be so fortunate as to
exchange wrong opinions for better ones. I
must, however, make a confession, because I
best know the character of my party, and own
that they are more easily conquered than con- vinced.
1 By the " men of the mountain or the plain," Jerome appears to contemptuously designate the Circumcelhons who were
an extreme section of the Donatists. They roamed about the
couajry in bands of both sexes, and struck terror into the
peaceable inhabitants. They were guilty of the grossest ex-
cesses, and no Catholic was safe except in the towns. Robert-
son's ''Hist, of the Church," vol. i. fourth ed. pp. 200, 419, and the original authorities there referred to.
THE PERPETUAL VIRGINITY OF BLESSED MARY.
Against Helvidius.
This tract appeared about A.D. 383. The question which gave occasion to it was whether the Mother of
our Lord remained a Virgin after His birth. Helvidius maintained that the mention in the Gospels of the
"sisters" and "brethren " of our Lord was proof that the Blessed Virgin had subsequent issue, and he sup- ported his opinion by the writings of Tertullian and Victorinus. The outcome of his views was that virginity
was ranked below matrimony. Jerome vigorously takes the other side, and tries to prove that the "sisters
and "brethren " spoken of, were either children of Joseph by a former marriage, or first cousins, children of
the sister of the Virgin. A detailed account of the controversy will be found in Farrar's "Early Days of
Christianity," pp. 124 sq. When Jerome wrote this treatise both he and Helvidius were at Rome, and Damasus was Pope. The only contemporary notice preserved of Helvidius is that by Jerome in the following pages.
Jerome maintains against Helvidius three propositions : —
1st. That Joseph was only putatively, not really, the husband of Mary.
2d. That the " brethren " of the Lord were his cousins, not his own brethren. 3d. That virginity is better than the married state.
1. The first of these occupies ch. 3-8. It turns upon the record in Matt. i. 18-25, an<i especially on the
words, " Before they came together " (c. 4;, " knew her not till, &c." (5-8).
2. The second (c. 9-17) turns upon the words " first-born son" (9, 10). which, Jerome argues, are applicable not only to the eldest of several, but also to an only son : and the mention of brothers and sisters, whom Jerome
asserts to have been children of Mary the wife of Cleophas or Clopas (11-16); he appeals to many Church writers in support of this view (17).