31. Now, such a troublous time was the time at which Hilary wrote in the passage which
you have thought fit artfully to adduce against so many Divine testimonies, as if by it you
could prove that the Church has perished from the earth.2233 You may just as well say that
the numerous churches of Galatia had no existence at the time when the apostle wrote to
them: “O foolish Galatians, who hath bewitched you,” that, “having begun in the Spirit, ye
are now made perfect in the flesh?”2234 For thus you would misrepresent that learned man,
who (like the apostle) was sternly rebuking the slow of heart and the timid, for whom he
was travailing in birth a second time, until Christ should be formed in them.2235 For who
does not know that many persons of weak judgment were at that time deluded by ambiguous
phrases, so that they thought that the Arians believed the same doctrines as they themselves
held; and that others, through fear, had yielded and feigned consent, not walking uprightly
according to the truth of the gospel, to whom you would have denied that forgiveness which,
when they had been turned from their error, was extended to them? But in refusing such
pardon, you prove yourselves wholly ignorant of the word of God. For read what Paul has
recorded concerning Peter,2236 and what Cyprian has expressed as his view on the ground
of that statement, and do not blame the compassion of the Church, which does not scatter
the members of Christ when they are gathered together, but labours to gather His scattered
members into one. It is true that those who then stood most resolute, and were able to un-
394
derstand the treacherous phrases used by the heretics, were few in number when compared
with the rest; but some of them it is to be remembered were then bravely enduring sentence
of banishment, and others were hiding themselves for safety in all parts of the world. And
thus the Church, which is increasing throughout all nations, has been preserved as the Lord’s
wheat, and shall be preserved unto the end, yea, until all nations, even the barbarous tribes,
are within its embrace. For it is the Church which the Son of man has sown as good seed,
and of which He has foretold that it should grow among the tares until the harvest. For the
field is the world, and the harvest is the end of time.2237
32. Hilary, therefore, either was rebuking not the wheat, but the tares, in those ten
provinces of Asia, or was addressing himself to the wheat, because it was endangered through
some unfaithfulness, and spoke as one who thought that the rebuke would be useful in
proportion to the vehemence with which it was given. For the canonical Scriptures contain
2233 Vincentius had quoted from Hilary’s work, De Synodis adversum Arianos, a sentence to the effect that,
with the exception of a very small remnant, the ten provinces of Asia in which he was settled were truly ignorant
of God.
2234 Gal. iii. 1, 3.
2235 Gal. iv. 19.
2236 Gal. ii. 11–21.
2237 Matt. xiii. 24–39.
867
To Vincentius