LETTER CXXXIII.
277
You say that the commandments of God
are easy, and yet you cannot produce any one who has fulfilled them all. Answer me
this : are they easy or are they difficult ? If
they are easy, then produce some one who
has fulfilled them all. Explain also the words
of the psalmist : " thou dost cause toil by
thy law," l and " because of the words of thy
lips I have kept hard ways."1 And make
plain our Lord's sayings in the gospel : " enter
ye in at the strait gate ; " 3 and " love your
enemies ; " and " pray for them which perse-
cute you." 4 If on the other hand the com- mandments are difficult and if no man has
kept them all, how have you presumed to say
that they are easy? Do not you see that you
contradict yourself ? For either they are
easy and countless numbers have kept them ;
or they are difficult and you have been too
hasty in calling them easy.
8. It is a common argument with your
party to say that God's commandments are either possible or impossible. So far as they
are the former you admit that they are
rightly laid upon us ; but so far as they are
the latter you allege that blame attaches not to us who have received them but to God
who has imposed them on us. What! has God
commanded me to be what He is,6 to put no difference between myself and my creator, to
be greater than the greatest of the angels, to
have a power which no angels possess ? Sin- lessness is made a characteristic of Ghrist,
" who did no sin neither was guile found in
his mouth." ' But if I am sinless as well as
He, how is sinlessness any longer His distin-
guishing mark ? for if this distinction exists,
your theory becomes fatal to itself.
You assert that a man may be without sin
if he will ; and then, as though awakening
from a deep sleep, you try to deceive the
unwary by adding the saving clause " yet
not without the grace of God." For if by his own efforts a man can keep himself with-
out sin, what need has he of God's grace ? If on the other hand he can do nothing
without this, what is the use of saying that
he can do what he cannot do ? It is argued
that a man may be without sin and perfect if
he only wills it. What Christian is there
who does not wish to be sinless or who would
reject perfection if, as you say, it is to be had
for the wishing, and if the will is sure to be
followed by the power ? There is no Chris-
tian who does not wish to be sinless ; wishing
to be so, therefore, they all will be so.
Whether you like it or not you will be caught
in this dilemma, that you can produce nobody
1 Ps. xciv. 20, LXX and Vulg. ' Matt. vii. 13.
6 oi/Top«i)9, self-determined.
* Ps. xvii. 4, LXX. 4 Matt. v. 44.
• i Pet. ii. 22.
or hardly anybody who is without sin, yet
have to admit that everybody may be sinless
if he likes. God's commandments, it is argued, are possible to keep. Who denies it ? But how this truth is to be understood
the chosen vessel thus most clearly explains :
" what the law could not do in that it was
weak through the flesh, God, sending his own
Son in the likeness of sinful flesh and for sin,
condemned sin in the flesh ; " ' and again :
" by the deeds of the law there shall no flesh
be justified."2 And to shew that it is not only the law of Moses that is meant or all
those precepts which collectively are termed
the law, the same apostle writes : " I delight in the law of God after the inward man.
But I see another law in my members, war-
ring against the law of my mind, and bring-
ing me into captivity to the law of sin which
is in my members. O wretched man that I
am : who shall deliver me from the body of
this death ? The grace of God through
Jesus Christ our Lord." : Other words of
his further explain his meaning : " we know that the law is spiritual : but I am carnal,
sold under sin. For that which I do I know4 not : for what I would that do I not, but
what I hate that do I. If then I do that
which I would not, I consent unto the law
that it is good. Now then it is no more I that do it : but sin that dwelleth in me. For I
know that in me (that is, in my flesh) dwelleth
no good thing. For to will is present with
me : but how to perform that which is good
I find not. For the good that I would, I do
not : but the evil which I would not, that I do.
Now if I do that I would not, it is no more
I that do it, but sin that dwelleth in me."' 9. But you will demur to this and say that
I follow the teaching8 of the Manichseans and
others who make war against the church's doc- trine in the interest of their belief that there are
two natures diverse from one another and that
there is an evil nature which can in no wise be
changed. But it is not against me that you
must make this imputation but against the
apostle who knows well that God is one thing
and man another, that the flesh is weak and the
spirit strong.7 " The flesh lusteth against the spirit and the spirit against the flesh : and
these are contrary the one to the other : so
that ye cannot do the things that ye would."' But from me you will never hear that any
nature is essentially evil. Let us learn then from him who tells us so in what sense the
flesh is weak. Ask him why he has said :
1 Rom. viii. 3. * Rom. iii. 20.
3 Rom. vii. 22-25. In the Latin as in the Greek one word does
duty for ' grace ' and ' thanks.' * R. V. 5 Rom. vii. 14-20.
* This is the well known dualism of Manes (Manichaeus), who held that the physical world and the human body are essentially
evil. ' cf. Matt. xxvi. 41. 8 Gal. v. 17.