easily worsted; for it is no pleasure to me that my dearest friends should think me to be such
491
as I am not, since assuredly they love not me, but instead of me another under my name, if
they love not what I am, but what I am not; for in so far as they know me, or believe what
is true concerning me, I am loved by them; but in so far as they ascribe to me what they do
not know to be in me, they love another person, such as they suppose me to be. Cicero, the
prince of Roman orators, says of some one, “He never uttered a word which he would wish
to recall.” This commendation, though it seems to be the highest possible, is nevertheless
more likely to be true of a consummate fool than of a man perfectly wise; for it is true of
idiots,2569 that the more absurd and foolish they are, and the more their opinions diverge
from those universally held, the more likely are they to utter no word which they will wish
to recall; for to regret an evil, or foolish, or ill-timed word is characteristic of a wise man.
If, however, the words quoted are taken in a good sense, as intended to make us believe that
some one was such that, by reason of his speaking all things wisely, he never uttered any
word which he would wish to recall,—this we are, in accordance with sound piety, to believe
rather concerning men of God, who spoke as they were moved by the Holy Ghost, than
concerning the man whom Cicero commends. For my part, so far am I from this excellence,
that if I have uttered no word which I would wish to recall, it must be because I resemble
more the idiot than the wise man. The man whose writings are most worthy of the highest
authority is he who has uttered no word, I do not say which it would be his desire, but which
it would be his duty to recall. Let him that has not attained to this occupy the second rank
through his humility, since he cannot take the first rank through his wisdom. Since he has
been unable, with all his care, to exclude every expression whose use may be justly regretted,
let him acknowledge his regret for anything which, as he may now have discovered, ought
not to have been said.
4. Since, therefore, the words spoken by me which I would if I could recall, are not, as
my very dear friends suppose, few or none, but perhaps even more than my enemies imagine,
I am not gratified by such commendation as Cicero’s sentence, “He never uttered a word
which he would wish to recall,” but I am deeply distressed by the saying of Horace, “The
word once uttered cannot be recalled.”2570 This is the reason why I keep beside me, longer
than you wish or patiently bear, the books which I have written on difficult and important
questions on the book of Genesis and the doctrine of the Trinity, hoping that, if it be im-
possible to avoid having some things which may deservedly be found fault with, the number
of these may at least be smaller than it might have been, if, through impatient haste, the
works had been published without due deliberation; for you, as your letters indicate (our
holy brother and co-bishop Florentius having written me to this effect), are urgent for the
2569 Quos vulgo moriones vocant.
2570 Nescit vox missa reverti.
1053
To Marcellinus