Excursus on the Words γεννηθέντα οὐ ποιηθέντα .
(J. B. Lightfoot. The Apostolic Fathers—Part II. Vol. ii. Sec. I. pp. 90, et seqq.)
The Son is here [Ignat. Ad. Eph. vii.] declared to be γεννητὸς as man and ἀγέννητος as
God, for this is clearly shown to be the meaning from the parallel clauses. Such language
is not in accordance with later theological definitions, which carefully distinguished between
γενητός and γεννητός between ἀγένητος and ἀγέννητος; so that γενητός, ἀγένητος respect-
ively denied and affirmed the eternal existence, being equivalent to κτιστός, ἄκτιστος, while
γεννητός, ἀγέννητος described certain ontological relations, whether in time or in eternity.
In the later theological language, therefore, the Son was γεννητός even in his Godhead. See
esp. Joann. Damasc. de Fid. Orth. i. 8 [where he draws the conclusion that only the Father
is ἀγέννητος, and only the Son γεννητός].
There can be little doubt however, that Ignatius wrote γεννητός καὶ ἀγέννητος, though
his editors frequently alter it into γενητὸς καὶ ἀγένητος. For (1) the Greek ms. still retains
the double [Greek nun] ν, though the claims of orthodoxy would be a temptation to scribes
5
to substitute the single ν. And to this reading also the Latin genitus et ingenitus points. On
the other hand it cannot be concluded that translators who give factus et non factus had the
words with one ν, for this was after all what Ignatius meant by the double ν, and they would
naturally render his words so as to make his orthodoxy apparent. (2) When Theodoret
writes γεννητὸς ἐξ ἀγεννήτου, it is clear that he, or the person before him who first substi-
tuted this reading, must have read γεννητὸς καὶ ἀγέννητος, for there would be no temptation
to alter the perfectly orthodox γενητὸς καὶ ἀγένητος, nor (if altered) would it have taken
this form. (3) When the interpolator substitutes ὁ μόνος ἄληθινὸς Θεὸς ὁ ἀγέννητος…τοῦ
δὲ μονογονοῦς πατῂρ καὶ γεννήτωρ, the natural inference is that he too, had the forms in
double ν, which he retained, at the same time altering the whole run of the sentence so as
not to do violence to his own doctrinal views; see Bull Def. Fid. Nic. ii. 2 § 6. (4) The quota-
tion in Athanasius is more difficult. The mss. vary, and his editors write γενητὸς καὶ
ἀγένητος. Zahn too, who has paid more attention to this point than any previous editor of
Ignatius, in his former work (Ign. v. Ant. p. 564), supposed Athanasius to have read and
written the words with a single ν, though in his subsequent edition of Ignatius (p. 338) he
declares himself unable to determine between the single and double ν. I believe, however,
that the argument of Athanasius decides in favour of the νν. Elsewhere he insists repeatedly
on the distinction between κτίζειν and γεννᾶν, justifying the use of the latter term as applied
to the divinity of the Son, and defending the statement in the Nicene Creed γεννητὸν ἐκ
τῆς οὐσίας τοῦ πατρὸς τὸν υἱὸν ὁμοούσιον (De Synod. 54, 1, p. 612). Although he is not
responsible for the language of the Macrostich (De Synod. 3, 1, p. 590), and would have re-
garded it as inadequate without the ὁμοούσιον, yet this use of terms entirely harmonizes
with his own. In the passage before us, ib. §§ 46, 47 (p. 607), he is defending the use of
homousios at Nicæa, notwithstanding that it had been previously rejected by the council
Excursus on the Words γεννηθέντα οὐ ποιηθέντα.”
45
Excursus on the Words .”