approve themselves to God here, will a thousand times rather choose to have, was it but one
table or half a table of honest communicants, true believers and real saints, than have a
hundred tables, by admitting any that are unworthy, (or Christless souls, as he anon charac-
terizes them,) of whom there are not moral evidences of their fitness for this holy ordinance.
And for the commendable practice of the church of Scotland, in being pointed and particular
in debarring the unworthy from this ordinance, (says he,) God forbid ever it turn into desu-
etude. I think I may here not unfitly subjoin those remarkable passages in Mr. Anderson’s
excellent Defence of the Presbyterians, against Mr. Rhind; where he informs us, they look
upon this holy ordinance as the common privilege of the faithful; and therefore they usually
fence the Lord’s table, in the words of Scripture, 1 Cor. vi. 9. or some such-like. To exclude
the impenitent from the privilege of gospel-mysteries; to debar those from the Lord’s table,
whom the Lord has, by the express sentence of his word, debarred out of the kingdom of
heaven, is what every one, who is not quite lost in impiety, must own to be not only lawful,
but a duty. Upon which I beg leave to observe, according to this principle I do not see but
that a man who with apparent signs of credibility confesses himself habitually impenitent,
ought to be debarred from the Lord’s table: and surely, by parity of reason, he that knows
himself to be unregenerate, ought to refrain coming, since there can be no true repentance
without regeneration. I think we have no just grounds to suppose Mr. Stoddard’s principle
in this matter has hitherto any general prevalence in the church of Scotland.
And now to pass over to England, neither do I find reason to think the dissenters there
in general are for Mr. Stoddard’s latitude. The Assembly of Divines pronounce all the ungodly,
as well as ignorant, unworthy of the Lord’s table; direct to preparation for it, by examining
ourselves of our being in Christ, &c. And though they declare this sacrament appointed for
the relief even of the weak and doubting Christian, who unfeignedly, desires to be found in
Christ; and having directed such a one to bewail his unbelief and labour to have his doubts
resolved, they assert that so doing he may and ought to come to the Lord’s supper, to be
further strengthened: yet I do not find any appearance of a hint, as if others who know
themselves to be in a natural state, or are conscious of their being certainly graceless, may
and ought to come to this ordinance, that they may be converted. Nay, they expressly declare
of all ungodly persons, that while they remain such, they cannot without great sin against
Christ partake of those holy mysteries.—As to particular divines, I find multitudes of them
among the dissenters, in later as well as former times, expressing the same sentiments: dis-
481
tinguishing between natural and instituted duties, between initial and confirming means,
between special ordinances and common: and declaring the Lord’s supper a disciple-privilege,
peculiar to such as have disciple-properties, and admonishing as well the close hypocrite, as
the more gross, of the sin and danger of coming to it in his unregenerate state, impenitent
and unbelieving. Thus Mr. Bolton, in his discourse on the Wedding Supper and the Wedding
Garment, warns the graceless not to come to the Lord’s supper; affirming, that an unsanctified
1882
Appendix. Mr. Foxcroft's letter.