Elucidations.
I.
(The Lord’s Discipline,
book iv.
cap. vi.
p. 413.)
ἡ κυριακὴ
ἄσκησις
. Casaubon
explains this as
Dominica exercitatio
(the
religion
which the Lord taught), and quotes the apostolic canons (li. and
lii.), which, using this word (
ἄσκησις
),
ordain certain fasts
on account of pious exercise
. Baronius,
more suo
, grasps at this word
ἄσκησις
,
as a peg to hang the system of monkery upon. Casaubon answers: “If
so, then all the early Christians were monks and nuns; as this word is
always used by the Fathers for the Christian discipline, or Christianity
itself.” Such are the original
ascetics,
nothing more. The
Christian Fathers transferred the word from heathen use to that of the
Church, to signify the training to which
all the faithful
should
subject themselves, in obedience to St. Paul (
1 Cor. ix. 24–27
). See
Isaaci Casauboni,
De Annalibus Baronianis Exercitationes
,
p. 171.
II.
(Theano,
cap. xix.
p. 431.)
The translator has not been happy
in this rendering, but I retain it as in the Edinburgh Edition, which
leaves one in doubt whether this second saying was Theano’s; for,
possibly, the translator meant to leave it so. But the Migne note is very
good: “Jamblichus mentions two Theanos, one the wife of Brontinus,
or Brotinus, and the other of Pythagoras. Both alike were devoted to
the Pythagorean philosophy; and it is not certain, therefore, to which
of them these
dicta
belong.”
Theodoret quotes both, but
decides not this doubt. Hoffman says, “There were many of the
name;” and he mentions five different ones. Suidas makes mention
of Theano of Crotona as the wife of Pythagoras, “the first woman
who philosophized and wrote poetry;” and Hoffman doubts not
this lady is the one quoted by Clement. She seems to have presided
over the school of her husband after his death. Of the beauty and
morality of the second
dictum
, I have spoken already (p. 348,
Elucidation XI
.); and I think it worth whole volumes
of casuistry on a subject which (
naturâ duce,
sub lege Logi
) the Gospel modestly leaves to natural decency and
enlightened conscience. (See Clement’s fine remarks, on p. 435.
III.
(St. Paul,
note 4
, p. 434.)
Better rendered, “Paul is more
recent (or later) in respect of time.” This seems a strangely
apologetic way to speak of this glorious apostle; though the reference
may be to his own words (
1 Cor. xv. 8
), “as of one born out
of due time.” And it suggests to me, that, among the Alexandrian
Christians, there were many Jewish converts who said, “I am
of Apollos,” and with whom the name of the great apostle of the
Gentiles was still unsavoury. This goes to confirm the Pauline origin of
the Epistle to the Hebrews, so far as it accounts for (what is testified
by Eusebius, vi. 14) his omission of his own name from his treatise,
lest it should prejudice his argument with his Hebrew kinsmen. Apollos
may have sent it to Alexandria.
IV.
(Socrates,
cap. xxii.
p. 436.)
Who can read the
Phædo
, and
think of Plato and Socrates, without hope that the mystery of redemption
applies to them in some effectual way, under St. Paul’s maxims
(
Rom. ii. 26
)? It would torture me in reading such sayings as are quoted
here, were I not able reverently to indulge such hope, and then
to
desist from speculation
. Cannot we be silent where Scripture is
silent, and leave all to Him who loved the Gentiles, and died for them on
the cross? I suspect the itch of our times, on this and like subjects,
to be presumption (
2 Cor. x. 5
) “against the obedience of
Christ.” As if our own concern for the heathen were greater than
His who died for the unjust, praying for His murderers! Why not leave
the ransomed world to the world’s Redeemer? The cross bore the
inscription in Greek, and Latin also; for the Jews scorned it in Hebrew:
and who can doubt that those outstretched arms embraced all mankind?
V.
(Basilides answered,
cap. xxiv.
p. 437.)
Note the pith and point of this
chapter, and the beauty of Clement’s
dictum
, “So it
would be, were it a man and not God that justifies! As it is written, Thou
thoughtest that I was altogether such an one as thyself.” (Compare
Matt. xx. 14
.) But let us not overlook his exposition of the ends and
purposes of chastisement. The great principle which he lays down destroys
the whole Trent theology about penance, and annihilates the logical base
of its figment about “Purgatory.” “Punishment does
not avail to him who has sinned, to undo his sin.” The precious
blood of Christ “speaketh better things.”
VI.
(Sin after Baptism,
cap. xxiv.
p. 438.)
Not to broach any opinion of my own,
it is enough to remark, that this reference to primitive discipline
shows that a defined penitential system in the early Church was aimed
at by the Montanists,
and inspired their deadly animosity,
not merely as a theory, but as a system. Although differing on many
points with Dr. Bunsen (he is both Baron and Doctor, and I give him
the more honourable title of the two), I feel it due to my contract
with the reader of this series to refer him to what he says of the
baptismal vow, etc. (
Hippol
., iii. p. 187), as furnishing a
valuable commentary on the text, and on the whole plan of Alexandrian
teaching and discipline.
VII.
(Jubilee,
cap. xxv.
p. 438.)
Here the reader may feel that
an Elucidation is requisite to any intelligent idea of what Clement
means to say. “We wish he would explain his explanation”
of Ezekiel. Let me give a brief rendering of the annotations in Migne,
as all that can here be furnished. (1) The
tabernacle
is the body,
as St. Paul uses the word (
2 Cor. v. 1–4
), and St. Peter (2 Ep. i. 13,
14). (2) The
seven periods
are the Sabbatical weeks of years
leading up to the year of Jubilee. (3) The
ἀπλανὴς
χώρα
refers to the old system of astronomy,
and its division of the heavens into an octave of
spheres,
of
which the seven inner spheres are those of the seven planets; the fixt
stars being in the eighth, which “borders on the intellectual
world,”—the abode of spirits, according to Clement.
The Miltonic student will recall the perplexity
with which, perhaps, in early years, he first read:—
“They pass the planets seven, and pass the fixt,
And that crystalline sphere whose balance weighs
The trepidation talked, and that first moved.
Paradise Lost
, book
iii. 481.
The Copernican system was, even
in Milton’s time, not generally accepted; but, for one who had
personally conversed with Galileo, this seems incorrigibly bad. The true
system would have given greater dignity, and in fact a better topography,
to his great poem.
VIII.
(Rebecca,
p. 439
.)
Le Nourry, as well as Barbeyrac
(see Kaye, pp. 109 and 473), regards Clement as ignorant of the
Hebrew language. Kaye, though he shows that some of the attempts
to demonstrate this are fanciful, inclines to the same opinion;
remarking that he borrows his interpretations from Philo. On
the passage here under consideration, he observes, that,
“having said repeatedly
2942
that
Rebekah in Hebrew is equivalent to
ὑπομονὴ
in Greek, he now makes it equivalent to
Θεοῦ
δόξα
. He elsewhere refers our Saviour’s
exclamation, Eli, Eli, etc., to the Greek word
ἡλιος
,
and the name Jesus to
ἰᾶσθαι
.”
IX.
(Plato’s City,
cap. xxvi.
p. 441.)
This is worth quoting from the
Republic
(book ix. p. 423, Jowett): “In heaven there is laid
up a pattern of such a city; and he who desires may behold this, and,
beholding, govern himself accordingly; He will act according to the laws
of that city, and of no other.” Sublime old Gentile! Did not the
apostle of the Gentiles think of Socrates, when he wrote
Heb. xii. 28
,
and xiii. 14? On this noble passage, of which Clement has evidently
thought very seriously, Schleiermacher’s remarks seem to me cold
and unsatisfactory. (See his
Introductions
, translated by Dobson;
ed. Cambridge, 1836.)
2942
e.g., this vol., p. 309.