same thing as destruction. This, then, is the upshot of our controversialist’s victory over us;
to show us the God of his imagining whom he has fashioned by the name ungeneracy—speak-
ing, indeed, that He may not lose His share in the invention of names, but provided with
vocal organs with which to utter them, and not without bodily nature to enable Him to
employ them (for you cannot conceive of formal utterance in the abstract apart from a
body), and gradually going on to the congenital affections of the body—through the com-
posite to dissolution, and so finding His end in destruction.
Such is the nature of this new-fangled Deity, as deducible from the words of our new
God-maker. But he takes his stand on the Scriptures, and maintains that Moses explicitly
declares this, when he says, “God said,” adding His words, “Let there be light,” and, “Let
there be a firmament,” and, “Let the waters be gathered together…and let the dry land ap-
pear,” and, “Let the earth bring forth,” and, “Let the waters bring forth,” and, whatsoever
else is written in its order. Let us, then, examine the meaning of what is said. Who does not
know, even if he be the merest simpleton, that there is a natural correlation between hearing
271
and speech, and that, as it is impossible for hearing to discharge its function when no one
is speaking, so speech is ineffectual unless directed to hearing? If, then, he means literally
that “God said,” let him tell us also to what hearing His words were addressed. Does he
mean that He said them to Himself? If so, the commands which He issues, He issues to
Himself. Yet who will accept this interpretation, that God sits upon His throne prescribing
what He Himself must do, and employing Himself as His minister to do His bidding? But
even supposing one were to allow that it was not blasphemy to say this, who has any need
of words and speech for himself, even though a man? For every one’s own mental action
suffices him to produce choice and volition. But he will doubtless say that the Father held
converse with the Son. But what need of vocal utterance for that? For it is a property of
bodily nature to signify the thoughts of the heart by means of words, whence also written
characters equivalent to speech were invented for the expression of thought. For we declare
thought equally by speaking and by writing, but in the case of those who are not too far
distant we reach their hearing by voice, but declare our mind to those who are at a distance
by written characters; and in the case of those present with us, in proportion to their distance
from us, we raise or lower the tones of our voice, and to those close by us we sometimes
point out what they are to do simply by a nod; and such or such an expression of the eye is
sufficient to convey our determination, or a movement of the hand is sufficient to signify
our approval or disapproval of something going on. If, then, those who are encompassed
by the body are able to make known the hidden working of their minds to their neighbours,
even without voice, or speech, or correspondence by means of letters, and silence causes no
hindrance to the despatch of business, can it be that in the case of the immaterial, and intan-
gible, and, as Eunomius says, the Supreme and first Being, there is any need of words to in-
dicate the thought of the Father and to make known His will to the Only-Begotten
512
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.