evidence for the circumstances which he records, and uncommonly shrewd in detecting
spurious and unreliable sources. When we remember the great number of pseudonymous
works which were current in his day we are compelled to admire his care and his discrimin-
ation. Not that he always succeeded in detecting the false. More than once he was sadly at
fault (as for instance in regard to the Abgarus correspondence and Josephus’ testimony to
Christ), and has in consequence been severely denounced or held up to unsparing ridicule
by many modern writers. But the wonder certainly is not that he erred as often as he did,
49
but that he did not err oftener; not that he was sometimes careless in regard to the reliability
of his sources, but that he was ever as careful as, in the majority of cases, he has proved
himself to be. In fact, comparing him with other writers of antiquity, we cannot commend
too highly the care and the skill with which he usually discriminated between the true and
the false.
In the fourth place, he deserves all praise for his constant sincerity and unfailing honesty.
I believe that emphasis should be laid upon this point for the reason that Eusebius’ reputation
has often suffered sadly in consequence of the unjust imputations, and the violent accusations,
which it was for a long time the fashion to make against him, and which lead many still to
treat his statements with distrust, and his character with contempt. Gibbon’s estimate of
his honesty is well known and has been unquestioningly accepted in many quarters, but it
is none the less unjust, and in its implications quite untrue to the facts. Eusebius does dwell
with greater fullness upon the virtues than upon the vices of the early Church, upon its glory
than upon its shame, and he tells us directly that it is his intention so to do (H. E. VIII. 2),
but he never undertakes to conceal the sins of the Christians, and the chapter immediately
preceding contains a denunciation of their corruptness and wickedness uttered in no faint
terms. In fact, in the face of these and other candid passages in his work, it is the sheerest
injustice to charge him with dishonesty and unfairness because he prefers, as almost any
Christian historian must, to dwell with greater fullness of detail upon the bright than upon
the dark side of the picture. Scientific, Eusebius’ method, in this respect, doubtless is not;
but dishonest, no one has a right to call it. The most severe attack which has been made
upon Eusebius in recent years is found in an article by Jachmann (see below, p. 55). The
evident animus which runs through his entire paper is very unpleasant; the conclusions
which he draws are, to say the least, strained. I cannot enter here into a consideration of his
positions; most of them are examined below in the notes upon the various passages which
he discusses. The whole article, like most similar attacks, proceeds upon the supposition
that our author is guilty, and then undertakes simply to find evidence of that which is already
presupposed. I submit that few writers could endure such an ordeal. If Eusebius is tried ac-
cording to the principles of common justice, and of sound literary criticism, I am convinced,
after long and careful study, that his sincerity and honesty of purpose cannot be impeached.
The particular instances which have been urged as proving his dishonesty will be discussed
74
Eusebius as a Historian. The Merits and Defects of his History.