In great men, and only in great men, great opposites and apparently antagonistic truths
live together. Small minds cannot hold them. The catholic, churchly, sacramental, and sa-
cerdotal system stands in conflict with the evangelical Protestant Christianity of subjective,
personal experience. The doctrine of universal baptismal regeneration, in particular, which
presupposes a universal call (at least within the church), can on principles of logic hardly
be united with the doctrine of an absolute predestination, which limits the decree of redemp-
tion to a portion of the baptized. Augustin supposes, on the one hand, that every baptized
person, through the inward operation of the Holy Ghost, which accompanies the outward
act of the sacrament, receives the forgiveness of sins, and is translated from the state of
nature into the state of grace, and thus, qua baptizatus, is also a child of God and an heir of
eternal life; and yet, on the other hand, he makes all these benefits dependent on the absolute
will of God, who saves only a certain number out of the “mass of perdition,” and preserves
these to the end. Regeneration and election, with him, do not, as with Calvin, coincide. The
former may exist without the latter, but the latter cannot exist without the former. Augustin
assumes that many are actually born into the kingdom of grace only to perish again; Calvin
holds that in the case of the non-elect baptism is an unmeaning ceremony; the one putting
the delusion in the inward effect, the other in the outward form. The sacramental, churchly
system throws the main stress upon the baptismal regeneration, to the injury of the eternal
election; the Calvinistic or Puritan system sacrifices the virtue of the sacrament to the election;
the Lutheran and high Anglican systems seek a middle ground, without being able to give
a satisfactory theological solution of the problem. The Anglican Church, however allows
the two opposite views, and sanctions the one in the baptismal service of the Book of
Common Prayer, the other in her Thirty-nine Articles, and other standards, as interpreted
by the low church or evangelical party in a moderately Calvinistic sense.
It was an evident ordering of God, that Augustin’s theology, like the Latin Bible of
Jerome, appeared just in the transitional period of history, in which the old civilization was
passing away before the flood of barbarism, and a new order of things, under the guidance
of the Christian religion, was in preparation. The church, with her strong, imposing organ-
ization and her firm system of doctrine, must save Christianity amidst the chaotic turmoil
of the great migration, and must become a training-school for the barbarian nations of the
middle age.73
73 Guizot, the Protestant historian and statesman, very correctly says in his Histoire générale de la civilisation
en Europe (Deuxième lecon, p. 45 sq. ed. Bruxelles, 1850): “S’il n’eût pas été une église, je ne sais ce qui en serait
avenu au milieu de la chute de l’empire romain.…Si le christianisme n’eût été comme dans les premiers temps,
qu’une croyance, un sentiment, une conviction individuelle, on peut croire qu’il aurait succombé au milieu de la
dissolution de l’empire et de l’invasion des barbares. Il a succombé plus tard, en Asie et dans tous le nord de l’Afrique,
sous une invasion de même nature, sous l’invasion des barbares musulmans; il a succombé alors, quoiqu’il fût à
l’êtat d’institution, d’église constituée. A bien plus forte raison le même fait aurait pu arriver au moment de la
46
The Influence of St. Augustin on Posterity, and His Relation to Catholicism…