175
Book VIII.
Faustus maintains that to hold to the Old Testament after the giving of the New is putting
new cloth on an old garment. Augustin further explains the relation of the Old Testament
to the New, and reproaches the Manichæans with carnality.
1. Faustus said: Another reason for not receiving the Old Testament is, that I am
provided with the New; and Scripture says that old and new do not agree. For "no one
putteth a piece of new cloth unto an old garment, otherwise the rent is made worse."370 To
avoid making a worse rent, as you have done, I do not mix Christian newness with Hebrew
oldness. Every one accounts it mean, when a man has got a new dress, not to give the old
one to his inferiors. So, even if I were a Jew by birth, as the apostles were, it would be
proper for me, on receiving the New Testament, to discard the Old, as the apostles did. And
having the advantage of being born free from the yoke of bondage, and being early introduced
into the full liberty of Christ, what a foolish and ungrateful wretch I should be to put myself
again under the yoke! This is what Paul blames the Galatians for; because, going back to
circumcision, they turned again to the weak and beggarly elements, whereunto they desired
again to be in bondage.371 Why should I do what I see another blamed for doing? My going
into bondage would be worse than their returning to it.
2. Augustin replied: We have already shown sufficiently why and how we maintain
the authority of the Old Testament, not for the imitation of Jewish bondage, but for the
confirmation of Christian liberty. It is not I, but the apostle, who says, "All these things
happened to them as an example, and they were written for our admonition, on whom the
ends of the world are come."372 We do not therefore, as bondmen, observe what was enjoined
as predictive of us; but as free, we read what was written to confirm us. So any one may see
that the apostle remonstrates with the Galatians not for devoutly reading what Scripture
says of circumcision, but for superstitiously desiring to be circumcised. We do not put a
new cloth to an old garment, but we are instructed in the kingdom of heaven, like the
householder, whom the Lord describes as bringing out of his treasure things new and old.373
He who puts a new cloth to an old garment is the man who attempts spiritual self-denial
before he has renounced fleshly hope. Examine the passage, and you will see that, when the
Lord was asked about fasting, He replied, "No man putteth a new cloth to an old garment."
The disciples had still a carnal affection for the Lord; for they were afraid that, if He died,
they would lose Him. So He calls Peter Satan for dissuading Him from suffering, because
he understood not the things of God, but the things of men.374 The fleshly character of
370 Matt. ix. 16.
371 Gal. iv. 9.
372 1 Cor. x. 11.
373 Matt. xiii. 52.
374 Matt. xvi. 23.
Faustus maintains that to hold to the Old Testament after the giving of the New is putting new cloth on an old garment. Augustin further explains the relation of the Old Testament to the New, and reproaches the Manichæans with carnality.
297
Faustus maintains that to hold to the Old Testament after the giving of…