Testimonia

Publiek archief van verzamelde en verwerkte bronrecords.
Overzicht / Records / record

native-RTF-topic-module-record

Technische verwerking bevestigt geen inhoudelijke beoordeling of toestemming voor openbare publicatie.

record_key: bd26ce19a550c68e743e9dad97665f6822770ecea4e65ee0ded3ee7362a86a37
origineel ID: twm:b77856c8904ad7b84d3700d54ad3e9a4db995f52b994322e71b7f1a05605f60a:content:102 · verwerkingsstatus: Verwerkt, inhoudelijk nog niet beoordeeld · teksthash: a106a98d1dc951dd95a24d8ca9c7e49d4011f01c50d628ace9a2b7915d85c0f6 · 14,112 tekens

Tekst tekstblob openen

\par\par\pard (\cf13\b Then said Pilate unto them, Take ye him, and judge him according to your law. The Jews therefore said unto him, It is not lawful for us to put any man to death:) \par\par (\cf13\i [It is not lawful for us to put any man to death.]) Doth Pilate jest or deride them, when he bids them "take him, and judge him according to their own law?" It cannot be denied but that all capital judgment, or sentence upon life, had been taken from the Jews for above forty years before the destruction of Jerusalem, as they oftentimes themselves confess. But how came this to pass? It is commonly received, that the Romans, at this time the Jews' lords and masters, had taken from all their courts a power and capacity of judging the capital matters. We have spoken largely upon this subject in our notes upon (\cf11\ul Matthew 26:3). Let us superadd a few things here: \par\par "Rabh Cahna saith, When R. Ismael Bar Jose lay sick, they sent to him saying, 'Pray, sir, tell us two or three things which thou didst once tell us in the name of thy father.' He saith to them, 'A hundred and fourscore years before the destruction of the Temple, the wicked kingdom' (\cf15\i [the Rome empire]) reigned over Israel. Fourscore years before the destruction of the Temple, (\i they) " (\cf15\i [the fathers of the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim)]) "(\i determined about the uncleanness of the heathen land); and about glass vessels. Forty years before the destruction of the Temple, the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) removed and sat in the (\cf9\b Tabernae). What is the meaning of this tradition? Rabh Isaac Bar Abdimi saith, 'They did not judge (\i judgments of mulcts).' " The Gloss is: "Those are the judgments about finding any that offered violence, that entice a maid, and the price of a servant. When, therefore, they did not sit in the room (\cf9\b Gazith); they did not judge about these things; and so those judgments about mulcts or fines ceased." \par\par Here we have one part of their judiciary power lost, not taken away from them by the Romans, but falling of itself, as it were, out of the hands of the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim). Nor did the Romans indeed take away their power of judging in capital matters, but they, by their own oscitancy, supine and unreasonable lenity, lost it themselves. For so the Gemara goes on: \par\par "Rabh Nachman Bar Isaac saith, 'Let him not say that they did not judge judgments of mulcts, but that they did not judge capital judgments. And whence comes this? (\i When they saw that so many murderers multiplied upon them, that they could not well judge) and call them to account, they said, It is better for us that we remove from place to place, (\i for how can we otherwise) " (\cf15\i [sitting here and not punishing them]) "(\i not contract a guilt upon ourselves?) ' " \par\par They thought themselves obliged to punish murderers while they sat in the room (\i (\cf9\b Gazith); for the place itself engaged them to it). They are the words of the Gemarists. Upon which the Gloss: "The room (\cf9\b Gazith) was half of it within and half of it without the Holy Place. The reason of which was, that it was requisite that the council should sit near the Divine Majesty. Hence it is that they say, 'Whoever constitutes an unfit judge, is as if he planted a grove by the altar of the Lord: as it is written, Judges and officers shalt thou make thee': and it follows presently after, 'Thou shalt not plant thee a grove of any trees near unto the altar of the Lord thy God,' (\cf11\ul Deuteronomy 16:18); (\cf11\uk Deuteronomy 16:21). They removed therefore from (\cf9\b Gazith); and sat in the (\cf9\b Tabernae). Now though the (\cf9\b Tabernae) were upon the Mountain of the Temple, yet they did not sit so near the Divine Majesty there as they did when they sat in the room (\cf9\b Gazith)." \par\par Let us now, in order, put the whole matter together: \par\par I. The (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) were most stupidly and unreasonably remiss in their punishment of capital offenders, going upon this reason especially, that they accounted it so horrible a thing to sentence an Israelite to death. Forsooth, he is of the seed of Abraham, of the blood and stock of Israel; and you must have a care how you touch such a one! \par\par "R. Eliezer Bar R. Simeon had laid hold on some thieves. R. Joshua Bar Korchah sent to him, saying, '(\i O thou vinegar, the son of good wine) ' " (\cf15\i [i.e. O thou wicked son of a good father]), "'how long wilt thou deliver the people of God to the slaughter?' He answered and said, '(\i I root the thorns out of the vineyard).' To whom the other, 'Let the Lord of the vineyard come and root them out himself.' " It is worth nothing that the very thieves of Israel are the people of God: and O! they must not be touched by any means, but referred to the judgment of God himself. \par\par "When R. Ismael Bar R. Jose was constituted a magistrate by the king, there happened some such thing to him; for Elias himself rebuked him, saying, 'How long wilt thou deliver over the people of God to slaughter?' " Hence that which we alleged elsewhere: "The (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) that happens to sentence any one to death within the space of seven years is called 'a destroyer.' R. Eleazar Ben Azariah saith, 'It is so, if they should but condemn one within seventy years.' " \par\par II. It is obvious to any one, how this foolish remissness and letting loose the reins of judgment would soon increase the number of robbers, murderers, and all kind of wickedness: and, indeed, they did so abundantly multiply, that the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) neither could nor durst, as it ought, call the criminals to account. The laws slept while wickedness was in the height of its revels; and punitive justice was so out of countenance, that, as to uncertain murders, they made no search; and certain ones they framed no judgment against. \par\par "Since the time that homicides multiplied, the beheading the heifer ceased." And in the place before quoted in (\i Avodah); "When they saw the number of murderers so greatly increase, that they could not sit in judgment upon them, they said, 'Let us remove,' " etc. \par\par So in the case of adultery, which we also observed in our notes upon (\cf11\ul John_8). "Since the time that adultery so openly advanced under the second Temple, they let off trying the adulteress by the bitter water," etc. \par\par So that we see the liberty of judging in capital matters was no more taken from the Jews by the Romans than the beheading of the heifer or the trial of the suspected wife by the bitter waters was taken away by them; which no one will affirm. But rather, \par\par III. When the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) saw that it was in vain to struggle against the mighty torrent and inundation of all manner of wickedness, that (\i played rex) and encroached so fast upon them, and that the interposure of their authority could do nothing in suppressing them, they being incapable of passing judgment as they ought, they determine not to sit in judgment at all. And whereas they thought themselves bound by the majesty and awfulness of the place, while they sat in the room (\cf9\b Gazith) (\cf15\i [in the very Court of Israel before the altar]), to judge according to the sacredness of the place, but could not indeed do it by reason of the daring pride and resolution of the criminals, they threw themselves out of that apartment, and went further off into the place where the exchangers' shops were kept in the Court of the Gentiles, and so to other places, which we find mentioned in (\cf9\b Rosh hashanah). \par\par IV. It is disputed whether they ever returned to their first place (\cf9\b Gazith); or no. It is affirmed by the Gloss in (\cf9\b Avodah Zarah); "When for a time they found it absolutely necessary, they betook themselves again to that room." We have the same also elsewhere upon this tradition: \par\par "It is a tradition of R. Chaia. From the day wherein the Temple was destroyed, though the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) ceased, yet the four kinds of death" (\cf15\i [which were wont to be inflicted by the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim)]) "did not cease. For he that had deserved to be stoned to death, he either fell off from some house, or some wild beast tore and devoured him. He that had deserved burning, he either fell into some fire or some serpent bit him. He that had deserved to be slain: (\cf15\i [i.e. with the sword]), was either delivered into the hands of a heathen king, or was murdered by robbers. He that had deserved strangling was either drowned in some river, or choked by a squinancy (\cf15\i [angina])." \par\par But it may be objected, Why is it said, "From the time that the Temple was destroyed," and not, "forty years before the destruction of the Temple?" To this the Gloss answereth: "Sometimes, according to the urgency and necessity of the time, the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) returned to the room (\cf9\b Gazith);" etc. It is further excepted "(\i But they never returned to sit in capital causes, or to try murders). For the reason of their removal at first was because the numbers of homicides so increased upon them," etc. \par\par V. When the great council did not sit in Gazith, all courts for capital matters ceased everywhere else. One Gloss saith thus: "They took no cognizance of capital matters in any of the lesser sessions, so long as the great (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) did not sit in the room (\cf9\b Gazith)." Another saith; "What time the great (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) sat in its proper place, where it ought, near the altar, then thou shalt make thee judges in all thy gates, to judge in capital causes: but when that removed, then all cognizance about those matters ceased." \par\par VI. The (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) removed, as we have already seen, from (\cf9\b Gazith); forty years before Jerusalem was destroyed: and this is the very thing that was said, "Forty years before the destruction of the city, judgment in capital causes was taken away from them." And now let the reader judge what should be the reason of their being deprived of this privilege: whether the Romans were in fault; or whether rather the Jews, nay, the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) itself, had not brought it upon themselves. When the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) flitted from (\cf9\b Gazith); all judgment of this kind vanished, and upon what reasons they did thus flit we have learned from their own pens. \par\par We will not contend about the time when these forty years should first begin: though I am apt to think they might begin about half a year before Christ's death. The words which we have under consideration, spoken by the (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) to Pilate, seem to refer wholly to the reason we have already mentioned: "It is not lawful for us to put any man to death." Why is it not lawful? Because, being forced by the necessity of the times, we retired from the room (\cf9\b Gazith); where if we sit not, neither we ourselves nor any court under us can take any cognizance of causes of life and death. \par\par But what necessity of times could urge you to remove? So greatly did the criminals multiply, and grew to such a head, that we neither could not durst animadvert upon them, according to what the majesty of the place might expect and require from us if we should sit in (\cf9\b Gazith). \par\par That must be observed in the evangelists, that when they had had Christ in examination in the palace of the high priest all night, in the morning the whole (\cf9\b Sanhedrim) met, that they might pass sentence of death upon him. Where then was this that they met? Questionless in the room (\cf9\b Gazith); at least if they adhered to their own rules and constitutions: "Thither they betook themselves sometimes upon urgent necessity." The Gloss before quoted excepts "only the case of murder"; which, amongst all their false accusations, they never charged Christ with. \par\par But however suppose it were granted that the great council met either in the (\cf9\b Tabernae) or some other place, (which yet by no means agreed with their own tradition,) did they deal truly, and as the matter really and indeed was, with Pilate, when they tell him, "It is not lawful for us to put any man to death?" He had saith to them, "Take ye him, and judge him according to your law." We have indeed judged and condemned him, but we cannot put any one to death. Was this that they said in fact true? How came they then to stone the protomartyr Stephen? How came they to stone Ben Satda at Lydda? How came they to burn the priest's daughter alive that was taken in adultery? \par\par It is probable they had not put any one to death as yet, since the time that they had removed out of (\cf9\b Gazith); and so might the easilier persuade Pilate in that case. But their great design was to throw off the odium of Christ's death from themselves, at least amongst the vulgar crowd, fearing them, if the council themselves should have decreed his execution. They seek this evasion, therefore, which did not altogether want some colour and pretext of truth: and it succeeded according to what they did desire; Divine Providence so ordering it, as the evangelist intimates, (\cf11\ul John 18:32), "That the saying of Jesus might be fulfilled, which he spake, signifying what death he should die": that is, be crucified, according to the custom of the Romans. \par\par Whilst I am upon this thought, I cannot but reflect upon that passage, than which nothing is more worthy observation, in the whole description of the Roman beast in the Revelation, (\cf11\ul Revelation 13:4); "The dragon which gave power unto the beast." We cannot say this of the Assyrian, Babylonish, or any other monarchy; for the Holy Scriptures do not say it. But reason dictates, and the event itself tells us, that there was something acted by the Roman empire in behalf of the dragon which was not compatible with any other, that is, the putting of the Son of God to death. Which thing we must remember, as often as we recite that article of our creed, "He suffered under Pontius Pilate"; that is, was put to death by the Roman empire. \par\par

Versies (1)

Versie 06ba32838bcd234b2f0cbcfcbb7563d16cd680c1d0e09d899fd27106b8ed4f5f
{"RTF_parser_context":{"controls":{"f":1,"fs":1,"lang":1,"line":26,"ltrpar":1,"nowidctlpar":1,"par":2,"pard":1,"sa":1,"uc":1,"viewkind":1},"full_input_consumed":true,"metadata_destinations":{},"parser":"explicit-token-state-RichEdit-fragment-subset","source_docs":["https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/openspecs/exchange_server_protocols/ms-oxrtfex/205e1abf-b794-4fd0-b1e4-5210882233ab","https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/controls/about-text-object-model"],"unicode_escapes":0,"unknown_controls_accepted":false},"canonical_mapping_status":"native_coordinates_only; no canonical verse mapping inferred","footnote_boundary_status":"whole_native_row_preserved; no independent-note segmentation/count claim","id":"twm:b77856c8904ad7b84d3700d54ad3e9a4db995f52b994322e71b7f1a05605f60a:content:102","native_body_column":"data","native_link_search_rows":[],"native_module_metadata_ref":{"$context_sha256":"a11495af7cd4a4cfdc48c62ce8c4046a3f1347b815cef8dc584635dc1c66e9e3"},"native_reference":{"bible_refs":[{"bi":43,"ci":18,"content_type":null,"fvi":31,"topic_id":102,"tvi":31}],"data2":null,"topic_id":102},"native_rowid":102,"native_search":{"raw_field_sha256":"429d12abd7e0b39de8bb5441a5a42ce60629a1d9b0e96f6ea404fd4d9c5d8e93","source_pointer":{"native_column":"data","native_rowid":102,"native_table":"content_search","source_sha256":"b77856c8904ad7b84d3700d54ad3e9a4db995f52b994322e71b7f1a05605f60a"},"value":{"$text_sha256":"11d8abcdc9ee8c4ed7b20d327a2f5b31eeee5ba3e8b7860675c2b7d5ea0339fb"},"whitespace_only_equal":true},"native_table":"content","projection":"Full recognized native RTF token/state grammar; unknown controls remain explicit pending; complete raw RTF recoverable through CAS SQL pointer.","public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"native-RTF-topic-module-record","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_family_classification":"other_or_not_yet_classified","source_locator":{"$context_sha256":"6c0e51f408068a4aee3d31096f2ceaddfb6a2705f670f3b458a01e0f5422107d"},"source_origin_path":"A Commentary on the New Testament from the Talmud and Hebraica.cmt.twm","source_rtf_ref":{"native_column":"data","native_rowid":102,"native_table":"content","source_sha256":"b77856c8904ad7b84d3700d54ad3e9a4db995f52b994322e71b7f1a05605f60a"},"source_rtf_sha256":"51fa4b7b1acc450cddf175d606db1faadcf80fe3c21f993eb64ce00ede68aa46","source_sha256":"b77856c8904ad7b84d3700d54ad3e9a4db995f52b994322e71b7f1a05605f60a"}

references: [] | work_id: | origin: existing-native-module-whole-unit | source:

Plaatsingen (1)

OrdinalInputVersie
content:rowid:1024573406ba32838bcd234b2f0cbcfcbb7563d16cd680c1d0e09d899fd27106b8ed4f5f

Bijbelverwijzingen (0)

CoördinaatReferentie

Live-status (1)

Live IDStatusMatchesSchema
twm:b77856c8904ad7b84d3700d54ad3e9a4db995f52b994322e71b7f1a05605f60a:content:102processed_not_found_in_observed_live0