Chapter 102.—231. Petilianus said: "You, therefore, who prefer rather to be washed
with the most false of baptisms than to be regenerate, not only do not lay aside your sins,
but also load your souls with the offenses of criminals. For as the water of the guilty has
been abandoned by the Holy Spirit, so it is clearly filled full of the offenses of the traditors.
To any wretched man, then, who is baptized by one of this sort, we would say, If you have
wished to be free from falsehood, you are really drenched with falsity. If you desired to shut
out the sins of the flesh, you will, as the conscience of the guilty comes upon you, be partakers
likewise of their guilt. If you wished to extinguish the flames of avarice, you are drenched
with deceit, you are drenched with wickedness, you are drenched also with madness. Lastly,
if you believe that faith is identical in the giver and the receiver, you are drenched with the
blood of a brother by him who slays a man. And so it comes to pass that you, who had come
to baptism free from sin, return from baptism guilty of the sin of murder."
232. Augustin answered: I should like to come to argument with those who shouted
assent when they either heard or read those words of yours. For such men have not ears in
their hearts, but their heart in their ears. Yet let them read again and again, and consider,
and find out for themselves, not what the sound of those words is, but what they mean.
First of all, to sift the meaning of the last clause, "So it comes to pass," you say, "that you
who had come to baptism free from sin, return from baptism guilty of the sin of murder:"
tell me, to begin with, who there is that comes to baptism free from sin, with the single ex-
ception of Him who came to be baptized, not that His iniquity should be purged away, but
that an example of humility might be given us? For what shall be forgiven to one free from
sin? Or are you indeed endowed with such an eloquence, that you can show to us some
innocence which yet committeth sin? Do you not hear the words of Scripture saying, "No
one is clean from sin in Thy sight, not even the infant whose life is but of a single day upon
the earth?"2278 For whence else is it that one hastens even with infants to seek remission of
their sins? Do you not hear the words of another Scripture, "In sin did my mother conceive
me?"2279 In the next place, if a man returns a murderer, who had come without the guilt
of murder, merely because he receives baptism at a murderer’s hands, then all they who re-
turned from receiving baptism at the hands of Optatus were made partakers with Optatus.
Go now, and see with what face you cast in our teeth that we excite the wrath of kings against
you. Are you not afraid that as many satellites of Gildo will be sought for among you, as
there are men who may have been baptized by Optatus? Do you see at length how that
sentence of yours, like an empty bladder, has rattled not only with a meaningless sound,
but on your own head?
2278 Job xiv. 4, 5; cp. LXX.
2279 Ps. li. 5.
Chapter 102
1166
Chapter 102