II.—Special Prolegomena.
__________
§1. The Life of
Constantine.
1.
Editions
The
Life is found in the editions of Eusebius (compare list in Dr.
McGiffert’s Prolegomena) of 1544 (p. 117
a
–),
1612 (p. 301–), 1659, 1672, 1678, 1720 (p. 583–) and 1822
at least. The edition of Heinichen first published in 1830 (p.
1–332, 333–406, 407–500) and republished in 1869:
Eusebius Pamphili Vita Constantini et Panegyricus atque Constantini
ad sanctorum Coetum oratio. Recensuit cum annotatione critica atque
indicibus denuo edidit…Lipsiæ, Hermann Mendelssohn,
1869.
8
o
is the latest and best.
2.
Translations
The editions of
Latin
translations are very numerous. Basil. 1549, Portesius (V.C.
650–698, O.C. 698–715, no L.C.); Basil, 1557, Musculus
(V.C. 158–215, O.C. 217–231, no L.C.); Basil, 1559 (V.C.
650–698, O.C. 698–715); Par. 1562, Musculus (V.C.
160–218, O.C. 218–234); Antv. 1568 (?), Christophorson
(V.C. 224–306
a
, O.C.
306
b
–326
a
, L.C. 326
b
–361);
Basil, 1570, Portesius (V.C. 862–914, O.C. 915–932) and
Christophorson (L.C. 932–971); Paris, 1571, Christophorson
(258–341, 341–362, 362–397); Basil, 1579, Portesius
(V.C. 862–914, O.C. 915–932), and Christophorson (L.C.
923–971); Paris, 1581 (V.C. p. 214–297, O.C. 297–317,
L.C. 317–355); Colon. 1581, Christophorson (V.C. 195–268,
O.C. 269–286, L.C. 287–317); “1591
(Grynæus)”; Basil, 1611 (Grynæus), Christophorson (V.C.
118–170, O.C. 171–184, no L.C.); Paris, 1677, Valesius
(V.C. 164–232, O.C. 233–248; L.C. 249–275); Frf. ad
M. 1695, Valesius (328–465, 466–497, 498–549); Cambr.
1720 (Reading) Valesius; Cambr. 1746 (Reading) Valesius; 1822
(Zimmermann), Valesius (772–1046, 1047–1117,
1118–1232); Par. 1842 (Cailleau). The editions of 1612, 1659, and
1672 at least also have Latin translations. There is a
French
translation by J. Morin,
Histoire
de la délivrance de l’Église
, &c., Par. 1630,
fol., and
another by Cousin,
Par. 1675,
4º, and
1686,
4º.
There is a
German
translation by Stroth, Quedlinb. 1799, v. 2,
p. 141–468, and one by Molzberger. Kempten, 1880. For English
translations, see the following paragraph.
3.
English translations
The first English translation of
Eusebius was by Merideth Hanmer (compare Prolegomena of Dr. McGiffert).
The first editions of Hanmer did not contain the Life of Constantine.
It is a little hard to distinguish the early editions, but there were
at least three, and perhaps four, editions (1577 (76), 1585 (84), 1607,
1619?), before there was added in 1637 to the 1636 edition
(“fourth edition” not “fifth edition 1650,” as
Wood,
Athenæ Oxon.
), a translation by Wye Saltonstall as
follows:
Eusebius
|
His life of Constantine,
|
in foure
|
bookes.
|
With Constantine’s Oration to the Clergie |
… | London.
|
Printed by Thomas Cotes, for Michael Sparke,
and are to be
|
sold at the blue Bible in greene Arbour
|
1637
; fol. pp. (2) 1–106 (E), 107–132 (C),
133–163 (4) (L.C.). The dedication by the
“translator” is signed
Wye Saltonstall
. This was
reprinted:
London.
Printed by Abraham Miller,
dwelling in Black Friers, 1649.
fol., and
is probably the same as that quoted often (e.g. Hoffmann) as 1650. The
Life occupies p. 1–74. It was again reprinted,
London
,
1656
, fol., it is said, revised and enlarged. The former
editions having become exhausted, it was proposed to re-edit and
republish Hanmer’s (Saltonstall’s) version, but the editor
found it “a work of far greater labor to bring
Dr.
Hanmer’s Translation
to an agreement with the
Greek Text
of Valesius’ Edition
, than to make a
New One
,”
which latter thing he accordingly did and did well. It was published in
1682, with the following title:
The | Life | of | Constantine
| in four books, | Written in Greek, by Eusebius Pamphilus, Bishop of
Cæsarea in | Palestine; done into English from that edition set
forth by | Valesius, and Printed at Paris in the Year 1659. | Together
with | Valesius’s Annotations on the said Life, which are made |
English, and set at their proper places in the margin. | Hereto is also
annext the Emperour Constantine’s Oration to the | Convention of
the Saints, and Eusebius Pamphilus’s Speech concerning the
praises of Constantine, | spoken at his tricennalia. | Cambridge, |
Printed by John Hayes, Printer to the University, 1682
, fol. This was published with the 1683 edition of the
History, and so is properly 1683 in spite of title-page. In 1692 this
was reprinted with a general title-page, but otherwise identically the
same edition with same sub-titles and same paging. In 1709 a new
edition was published, also with the History, having substantially the
same matter on the title-page but
The second edition. London.
Printed for N. and J. Churchill, in the Year 1709.
In this paging
is the same (527–633), but there is preliminary matter added
before the History. This version is said by Crusé (compare also
Dr. McGiffert’s Prolegomena) to be by T. Shorting. Whoever it was
by, it was well done and most interesting. In the course of time,
however, it became antiquated in form, and there was added in 1845 to
the Bagster edition of the ecclesiastical historians an anonymous
translation:
The
|
Life
|
of
|
the Blessed Emperor
|
Constantine
, |
in four books
. |
From 306–337
a.d
|
By
|
Eusebius Pamphilus
| ... |
London:
|
Samuel Bagster
and Sons;
| ... |
MDCCCXLV
. 8º p. xx, 380. This
translation is in somewhat inflated style, which perhaps represents
Eusebius and Constantine better than a simpler one, but which sometimes
out-Herods Herod, as, e.g. in the oration of Constantine, p. 279, where
it takes fourteen English words to express seven Greek ones, “Far
otherwise has it been during the corrupt and lawless period of human
life” for “It was not thus in lawless times.” A
quotation from Matthew (
xxvi.
52
)
on p. 267 takes eight words in the original, twelve in the 1881 Revised
Version, sixteen in the phrase of Constantine, and twenty-two in this
translation. The translation is made from the edition of Valesius, not
the first of Heinichen, as appears from the division of Bk. I, chap.
10, and similar peculiarities. The present edition (1890) is a revision
of the translation of 1845 founded on the edition of
Heinichen.
4.
Author and date
Almost no fact of history is
unquestioned; therefore the unquestionable authorship of Eusebius has
been questioned. Some have made the author Macarius (compare Vog. Hist.
lit. p. 12), evidently on the ground of the letter (3. 52) which the
author says was addressed to himself, but which is to Macarius and
others, but there is no real doubt of the Eusebian authorship. It was
written after the death of Constantine (337), and therefore between 337
and 340, when Eusebius died. The interesting hypothesis of Meyer (p.
28) that it was perhaps written mainly in Constantine’s lifetime,
at the suggestion and under the direction of Constantine, to defend him
against charges brought, or which might be brought, against him, is
worth mentioning, although it is more ingenious than probable. The
headings of the chapters are by another, though probably not much
later, and a competent hand (cf. Lightfoot).
5.
Trustworthiness of Eusebius
The value of a writer is
determined by (1) His sources of knowledge, (2) His own intellectual
and moral ability. Again, the criticism of a given work seeks whether
the aim pro
posed for that work has been truly fulfilled. A man who attempts a
treatise on Geometry is not to be criticised because he omits mention
of sulphuric acid, or if he proposes a description of Wagner’s
music, because he does not produce a Helmholtz on Sound. The
application of these principles to Eusebius’ Life of Constantine
requires brief examination of 1. The proposed scope of the work. 2. The
character of the sources. 3. The intellectual and moral competency of
Eusebius on the premises.
(1)
The Scope of the
Work
. This is quite definitely outlined (i. 11). In contrast with
those who have recorded the evil deeds of other emperors and have thus
“become to those who by some favor had been kept apart from evil,
teachers not of good, but of what should be silenced in oblivion and
darkness,” he proposes to record the noble actions of this
emperor. He proposes, however, to pass over many things,—his
wars, personal bravery, victories, and successes, his legislative acts,
and many other things, and confine himself to such things as have
reference to his religious character. His aim, therefore, is distinctly
limited to his religious acts, and it is not stretching his meaning too
far to say, expressly limited to his virtuous actions.
(2)
Character of the
Sources
. Respecting this there is endless controversy. The fullness
of material is unquestionable, the intellectual competency of Eusebius
is almost equally so, and the questionings regard mainly whether the
author has made a proper use of material. Opinions are various, but
this does not mean that they are equally well grounded and valuable.
Some of the latest judgments are the most severe. Crivellucci (Livorno,
1888) calls it an historical novel, and Görres, in a review of
Crivellucci, agrees that it is worth less than the Panegyrics of
Eumenius and Nazarius, which is certainly milder than Manso’s (p.
222) “more shameless and lying” than these. Right or wrong,
this is a frequently repeated view. Some (Hely, p. 141) cannot speak
too strongly of the “contempt” which he
“deserves,” and accuse of “pious fraud” or the
next thing to it (Kestner, 1816, p. 67). For farther criticisms consult
the works cited by Dr. McGiffert under
Literature
, and the
special works on Eusebius cited in the
Literature
to Constantine
above,
passim
. The criticisms group generally around 1. The
suppression of the facts respecting the deaths of Crispus, &c., and
various others derogatory to Constantine. 2. The eulogistic tone and
coloring of the work, especially the very pietistic saintly sort of
flavor given to Constantine.
As to the suppression of facts,
note (1) That he gives entire warning of his plan. It would have been
artistically and ethically improper, in a work which distinctly sets
out with such purpose, to admit that class of facts. It takes more or
less from the value of the work, but it does not reflect on the general
trustworthiness of what is said. (2) No similar judgment is passed on
Eutropius, the Victors, Anonymous Valesianus or Zosimus, for not
mentioning his pious acts. (3) A comparison of most biographies of
living and dead presidents, kings, and emperors will be greatly to the
advantage, even, of this fourth century eulogist over those of our
boasted critical age.
As to the eulogistic and
exaggerated tone, observe (1) That it was more or less justified. That
is, the premises of the criticism which are substantially that
Constantine was not saintly or pietistic and was non-committal toward
Christianity, are false. His extreme testimony is backed by very
general testimony in the election of Constantine to technical
saintship. (2) That is compares well with modern eulogists and
extremely well with the contemporary Panegyrists of Constantine. (3)
That Eusebius takes care frequently to guard his statements by quoting
his source, as in the matter of the vision of the cross, or by
ascribing to hearsay.
In general, the work stands much
on the same level as the biographies of generals in the late civil war,
or of presidents, written by admiring members of their staffs or
cabinets, incorporat
ing authentic documents, intending to be truthful, and
generally succeeding, but yet full of the enthusiasm of admiring
friendship and inclined not to see, or to extenuate or even suppress,
faults and mistakes. Nevertheless, they are valuable on the positive
side as the real testimony to genuinely believed excellency by those in
the position to know intimately. Eusebius is, substantially, genuine.
Such supreme hypocrisy as would produce this work, without admiring
respect and
after its subject was dead
, is inconceivable in him.
All the unconscious turns of phrase show at least a consistent attitude
of mind. The work is, in brief, by a competent author, from ample
sources and without intentional falsification or misrepresentation. It
probably represents the current Christian view of the man as accurately
and honestly as any biography of Lincoln or the Emperor William written
within a year or two of their deaths has done. As we now think of these
two men whom doubtless inquisitive criticism might find to have faults,
so the Christians in general and his friend Eusebius in particular
thought of the Great Emperor. Compare discussion and literature of the
trustworthiness of Eusebius as a historical writer in the Prolegomena
of Dr. McGiffert in this volume.
6.
Value of the Work
That the work on any basis but
the untenable one of out-and-out forgery should be characterized as
“worthless” or “a mere romance” or “of
less value than the heathen panegyrists” is a curious bit of
psychological performance, for it does precisely what it grounds its
contempt for Eusebius on,—suppresses and exaggerates. Taking the
minimum residuum of the most penetrating criticism, and the work is yet
a source of primary value for understanding the man Constantine. This
residuum includes (1) The documents which the work contains. These
amount at the very least estimate to more than one-fourth of the whole
matter, and the appended oration of Constantine is nearly as much more.
(2) Many facts and details where there could be no possibility of
motive for falsifying. (3) Much which critical care can draw out of the
over-statements of eulogy.