1857-8] SEAT OF RELIGIOUS AUTHORITY 175
all, never mind. Are you shocked at my hard-heartedness
in calling the Princess's death opportune ? But after they
had once settled that they meant to marry, she must either
have died or been miraculously cured ; and I do not like
stories to resort to heart-complaints because they have
raised a question of right and wrong which it is not easy to
answer. That is my one objection to the story, otherwise I
think it very beautiful.
The same to the same
ALDERLEY EDGE, Jany. 27th, 1858.
It seems to me you hold the paramount authority of
the Church over the conscience ; while I hold the paramount
authority, for the individual, of the individual conscience.
For the community, I think the Church has paramount
authority in all matters of practice and discipline, and that
every member is bound to conform to her rules for the
sake of order ; just as we obey the laws, even if we do not
altogether approve them, so long as they involve no violation
of the conscience.
But for the individual, it seems to me, nothing can
supersede that inner sense of right and wrong, which I
believe to be the voice of the Holy Spirit in the heart.
But this voice never discovers truth systematically ; what a
man has learnt from it, is true, but only a point of the
Truth, and in determining its relations to other truth
in systematizing and reasoning from it there is scope for
innumerable errors ; yet no one will ever come nearer to
the truth by giving up one such point that he has clearly
seen. The greatest certainty of knowledge in all things is,
of course, attained when the individual perception or con-
viction is confirmed by the universal conviction of men;
and in religious truth, where a man's own heart gives
response to what the Church has always taught, he has
the greatest certainty that we can imagine it possible to
attain. But if the Church's doctrine has not been always
equally decided, or if it seems to him to contradict the