testimony of these witnesses;2105 the result of which was, that whereas objection had been
taken to Cæcilianus on the ground of his ordination to the office of bishop by Felix, against
whom it seemed that the charge of surrendering and burning the sacred books had been
made, the innocence of Felix in this matter was clearly established. Moreover, when Maximus
affirmed that Ingentius, a decurion of the town of Ziqua, had forged a letter of the ex-magis-
trate Cæcilianus, we found, on examining the Acts which were before us, that this same
Ingentius had been put on the rack2106 for that offence, and that the infliction of torture on
him was not, as alleged, on the ground of his affirming that he was a decurion of Ziqua.
Wherefore we desire you to send under a suitable guard to the court of Augustus Constantine
the said Ingentius, that in the presence and hearing of those who are now pleading in this
case, and who day after day persist in their complaints, it may be made manifest and fully
known that they labour in vain to excite odium against the bishop Cæcilianus, and to
clamour violently against him. This, we hope, will bring the people to desist, as they should
do, from such contentions, and to devote themselves with becoming reverence to their reli-
gious duties, undistracted by dissension among themselves.
5. Since you see, therefore, that these things are so, why do you provoke odium against
us on the ground of the imperial decrees which are in force against you, when you have
yourselves done all this before we followed your example? If emperors ought not to use their
authority in such cases, if care of these matters lies beyond the province of Christian emper-
ors, who urged your forefathers to remit the case of Cæcilianus, by the proconsul, to the
Emperor, and a second time to bring before the Emperor accusations against a bishop whom
you had somehow condemned in absence, and on his acquittal to invent and bring before
the same Emperor other calumnies against Felix, by whom the bishop aforesaid had been
ordained? And now, what other law is in force against your party than that decision of the
elder Constantine, to which your forefathers of their own choice appealed, which they ex-
371
torted from him by their importunate complaints, and which they preferred to the decision
of an episcopal tribunal? If you are dissatisfied with the decrees of emperors, who were the
first to compel the emperors to set these in array against you? For you have no more reason
for crying out against the Catholic Church because of the decrees of emperors against you,
than those men would have had for crying out against Daniel, who, after his deliverance,
were thrown in to be devoured by the same lions by which they first sought to have him
2105 The value of the evidence of these witnesses is apparent when we remember that they were all in a position
to speak from personal knowledge of the persecution in A.D. 303 (under Diocletian and Maximian), and had
in their public capacity some share in enforcing the demand made in that persecution for the surrender of the
sacred books. These could tell whether Felix the Bishop of Aptunga was guilty or not of the unfaithfulness to
his religion with which the faction of Majorinus reproached him.
2106 Suspensum.
824
To Januarius