17. This clause contains a second ground for the prohibition in v. 15. Not only is the love of the world irreconcileable with the love of the Father; but also, yet further, the fate of the world is included in its essential character. The world—the external system which occupied the place of God—was already when St John wrote in the act of dissolution and vanishing.
The words can also be taken as a second proof of the antagonism of the love of the Father and of the love of the world, so far as these are at variance in their issue no less than in their source. But this connexion appears to be less natural than the other.
παράγεται] is passing away: see v. 8. The word describes not the general character of the world as transitory but its actual condition in the face of the church, 'the Kingdom of God.' The whole sum of finite things, regarded in itself as complete, is (as it were) a screen which hides the presence of God. By the declaration of the Truth this was in St John's time beginning to be removed. Compare v. 8; 1 Cor. vii. 31; and contrast the ideal view from the divine side: τὰ ἀρχαῖα παρῆλθεν, ἰδοὺ γέγονεν καίνα (2 Cor. v. 17: comp. Apoc. xxi. 4).
In the thanksgiving after the Eucharist in The Doctrine of the Apostles the clause occurs: ἐλθέτω χάρις καὶ παρελθέτω ὁ κόσμος οὗτος (c. x. 6).
ἡ ἐπιθυμία αὐτοῦ] concupiscentia (desideria Aug.) ejus V., the desire thereof, the desire which belongs to it and which it stimulates. Comp. Tit. ii. 12 αἱ κοσμικαὶ ἐπιθυμία. The gen. is subjective as in v. 16, though it is true that the desire which the world fosters is in turn directed to the world as its object. A verb corresponding to παράγεται must be supplied. The world which is the source and the object of the desire is shewn to be by itself unsubstantial and evanescent. The desire therefore is shewn in its utter vanity (καταργεῖται). But the desire remains as an aching void.
The contrast to this 'desire' which is earth-born and empty is 'the will of God.' That alone is permanent of which this will is the ground.
ὁ δὲ ποιῶν...μένει...] qui autem facit (fecerit Aug.) V., but he that doeth...abideth... While the fabric of 'the world' is being removed the Christian suffers no disturbance. The present in this sense is eternal. When
all else changes the obedience of love continues unchanged. This abides in the new order to which indeed it properly belongs. The contrast to the world converted into an idol is not God, but the believer who in action strives to do God's will. Hence St John does not say 'he that loveth God,' which might have been suggested by v. 15, but he that doeth the will of God abideth for ever. Such a one is truly akin to the Son of man: Mk. iii. 35.
Compare John iv. 34; vi. 38; vii. 17; ix. 31.
The will of God expresses the true end of all things, and is opposed to 'the desire' which springs from a finite source as its ultimate origin. At the same time 'the will of God' includes the right use of all natural powers, faculties, instincts, which in their essential nature answer to it: Apoc. iv. 11. Compare 1 Thess. iv. 3.
In speaking of the divine will St John says 'the will of God' and not 'the will of the Father' as might seem to be suggested by v. 16. Stress is laid upon the divine majesty rather than upon the divine love. 'The will of the Father' is found only in St Matthew (vi. 10 our Father, vii. 21: xii. 50 my Father; comp. xviii. 14; xxvi. 42). The will of our God and Father occurs Gal. i. 4 (comp. Eph. i. 5, 9, 11). The will of God is not unfrequent: 1 Pet. ii. 15; iii. 17; iv. 19; Rom. i. 10; xii. 2; Heb. x. 36. In the Gospel of St John the phrase which is always used by the Lord is the will of Him that sent me: iv. 34; v. 30; vi. 38 ff. (vii. 17).
μένει εἰς τ. αλ.] abideth for ever. Comp. John viii. 35; xii. 34; 2 Cor. ix. 9 (LXX); 1 Pet. i. 25 (LXX). The absolute use of μένειν is not unfrequent: John xv. 16; 1 Pet. i. 23; Heb. x. 34.
εἰς τὸν αἰῶνα] in æternum V. This is the only form in which αἰών occurs in the Epistles (here and 2 John 2)
and Gospel (12 times) of St John, except the correlative ἐκ τοῦ αἰῶνος (John ix. 32). The phrase occurs independently of the LXX (1 Pet. i. 25; 2 Cor. ix. 9; Hebr. v. 6; vi. 20; vii. 17 ff.) only (with negative) in Matth. xxi. 19||Mk. xi. 14; Mk. iii. 29; 1 Cor. viii. 13 (Jude 13 εἰς αἰῶνα). [1 Pet. i 23 and 2 Pet. ii. 17 are false readings.] It is very common in the LXX. as the rendering of עולם, לעולם, עֲרֵי עוֹלָם. The thought contained in the words here is given by the addition which is found in Theb. and Old Lat. 'as God also abideth for ever' (sicut et ipse manet in æternum). Augustine reads the addition and remarks on the whole passage: Voluit te amor mundi, tene Christum. Propter te factus est temporalis ut tu fias æternus; quia et ille sic factus est temporalis ut maneret æternus.
And again: Terram diligis, terra eris. Deum diligis: quid dicam, Deus eris? Non audeo dicere ex me: scripturas audiamus Ego dixi, dii estis et filii altissimi omnes.
Additional Note on ii. 17. St John's teaching on creation.
St John's conception of creation.
The main conception of creation which is present in the writings of St John is expressed by the first notice which he makes of it: 'all things came into being (ἐγένετο) through [the Word]' (John i. 3). This statement sets aside the notions of eternal matter and of inherent evil in matter. 'There was when' the world 'was not' (John xvii. 5, 24); and, by implication, all things as made were good. The agency of the Word 'who was God' again excludes both the Gnostic idea of a Demiurge, a creator essentially inferior to God; and the idea of an abstract Monotheism, in which there is no living relation between the creature and the Creator; for as all things come into being 'through' the Word, so they are supported 'in' Him (John i. 3 ὁ γέγ. ἐν αὐτῷ ζωὴ ἦν note; comp. Col. i. 16 f.; Heb. i. 3). And yet more the use of the term ἐγένετο, 'came into being,' as distinguished from ἐκτίσθη 'were created,' suggests the thought that Creation is to be regarded (according to our apprehension) as a manifestation of a Divine law of love. Thus Creation (πάντα ἐγένετο δι' αὐτοῦ) answers to the Incarnation (ὁ λόγος σὰρξ ἐγένετο). All the unfolding and infolding of finite being to the last issue lies in the fulfilment of His will Who is love.
An order unfolded in spite of the irruption of darkness. A Divine 'must.'
The irruption of darkness, however, has hindered the normal progress of the counsel of God. This is obvious in 'the world' which falls within the range of man's observation. But in spite of the violation of the Divine order by man there is still a fulfilment of the counsel of God in the world. This is seen most distinctly in the record of the Lord's work. In the accomplishment of this there is a Divine necessity, a 'must' and a 'cannot' in the very nature of things; and also a Divine sequence in the unfolding of its parts.
This Divine 'must' (δεῖ) extends to the relation of the Forerunner to Christ (iii. 30); to the fulfilment of the work of God during an allotted time (ix. 4); to the Passion and Exaltation (iii. 14; xii. 34); to the Rising again (xx. 9); to the execution of a wider office (x. 16) (comp. Apoc. i. 1; iv. 1; xxii. 6; xvii. 10; xx. 3).
A Divine 'cannot.'
On the other hand there is also a 'cannot,' a moral, and not an external or arbitrary, impossibility in life. This defines, while it does not limit, the action of the Son: v. 19, 30 comp. Mark vi. 5. And so also it fixes the conditions of discipleship (iii. 5; vi. 44, 65; vii. 34, 36; viii. 21 f.; comp. xiii. 33, 36); of understanding (iii. 3; viii. 43 f.; xiv. 17); of faith (xii. 39; comp. v. 44); of fruitfulness (xv. 4 f.); of progress (xvi. 12); of character (1 John iii. 9).
These terms ('must,' 'cannot') lay open the conditions (so to speak) of A Divine the Lord's life. The Divine sequence in the course of its events is no less 'hour.' distinctly marked by the term 'hour.' The crises of the manifestations of the Lord are absolutely fixed in time (ii. 4; comp. xi. 9 f.; ix. 4). Till this hour comes His enemies are powerless (vii. 30; viii. 20). When it has come He recognises its advent (xii. 27; xvii. 1); and it is appointed with a view to the issue to which it leads (xii. 23; xiii. 1 ἵνα).
Compare iv. 21, 23; v. 25, 28; 1 John ii. 18; Apoc. xiv. 7, 15 (ὥρα); John vii. 6, 8 (καιρός); Eph. i. 10 τὸ πλήρωμα τῶν καιρῶν; Gal. iv. 4 τὸ πλήρωμα τοῦ χρόνου.
Under this same aspect the 'works' of the Lord are said to have been 'given' to Him (v. 36; xvii. 4). The circumstances which furnished the occasion for them are shewn to enter into the scheme of providence (ix. 3 ἵνα; xi. 4 ἵνα). Even unbelief was a necessity in regard of the history of mankind (xii. 38; xiii. 18; xv. 25; xvii. 12). This being so, Christ knew all 'the things that were coming upon Him' (xviii. 4; comp. xiii. 1, 11; vi. 64; comp. xviii. 9, 32). He laid down His life 'in order to take it again' (x. 17). This was His Father's will.
The whole life of Christ was thus a 'fulfilment,' 'a bringing to a perfect accomplishment' of all that had been shadowed forth or begun¹.
The same Divine appointment is extended to the discipline of the Church. The extremity of persecution is part of the revelation of the counsel of God (John xvi. 2 ἵνα, note), as even was the failure of the disciples at their Master's suffering (John xvi. 32 ἵνα, note). The birth of the Church has a real correspondence with the birth of the man (John xvi. 21 ff.). And in the work of service there is an appointed difference of function with a common end (John iv. 36 ff.).
The life of Christ and the life of the Church, as presented by St John, thus become revelations of a perfect order even in the disorder of the world lying beneath the surface of things, and veiled by suffering and by the workings of evil. In the same way he seems to indicate that below the transitory appearances of nature there is that which is Divine and abiding. 'The world passeth away (παράγεται) and the desire thereof' (1 John ii. 17, 8), but at the same time he looked for a new heaven and a new earth (Apoc. xxi. 1).
He recognised most sharply the difference between the natural and the unnatural in what we call Nature as a whole, and saw in the complete
The life of Christ, and the life of the Church according to law.
A true nature underneath appearances.
¹ The use of the two words πληρόω, τελειόω is worth study:
Of Holy Scripture and Divine words: ἵνα πληρωθῇ xii. 38; xiii. 18; xv. 25; xvii. 12; xviii. 32; xix. 24, 36. Comp. Apoc. vi. 11.
Of Holy Scripture: xix. 28 ἵνα τελ. ἡ γρ. Comp. τετέλεσται, xix. 28, 30; and Apoc. x. 7.
destruction of the unnatural, the restoration of Nature. In this position he stands alike removed from the Hellenic worship of nature and from the Gnostic degradation of nature. (Comp. Lutterbeck, Lehrb. d. Apost. ii. 270 f.)
{"canonical_mapping_status":"native_coordinates_only; no canonical mapping inferred","footnote_boundary_status":"whole_native_row_preserved; no independent-note segmentation or note-count claim","html_tags":{"b":6,"i":1,"p":36},"id":"sqlite3:280aa5b578b17d3dd9b56ec9d0f065a1b154f8e7c2e467799a3faacf064f545f:commentaries:28","native_body_column":"text","native_module_metadata":{"$context_sha256":"c696c188a5bc382915c66fa78834b5c544a6f2c23fc77ed893080f26b218c382"},"native_reference":{"book_number":690,"chapter_number_from":2,"chapter_number_to":2,"verse_number_from":17,"verse_number_to":17},"native_rowid":28,"native_table":"commentaries","projection":"HTML character data with explicit block newlines; no text-node deletion or whitespace folding; original HTML retained","public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"native-verse-keyed-module-record","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_family_classification":"sermonindex","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"04b927f28d21a438f6f5076e74974fa19c50c372322eb48c2f793f579f95821d"},"source_html_sha256":"04b927f28d21a438f6f5076e74974fa19c50c372322eb48c2f793f579f95821d","source_locator":{"$context_sha256":"2a8c06bf10237edc9987935a6bf5ce2f9c1b3d30a1a066b4a90d1c5c99739cf5"},"source_origin_path":"SI-WESTCOTT.commentaries.SQLite3","source_sha256":"280aa5b578b17d3dd9b56ec9d0f065a1b154f8e7c2e467799a3faacf064f545f"}