47. But, you say, if God is not the parent and father of souls, by what sire have they been
begotten, and how have they been produced? If you wish to hear unvarnished statements
not spun out with vain ostentation of words, we, too,3733 admit that we are ignorant of this,
452
do not know it;3734 and we hold that, to know so great a matter, is not only beyond the reach
of our weakness and frailty, but beyond that also of all the powers which are in the world,
and which have usurped the place of deities in men’s belief. But are we bound to show whose
they are, because we deny that they are God’s? That by no means3735 follows necessarily;
for if we were to deny that flies, beetles, and bugs, dormice, weevils, and moths,3736 are
made by the Almighty King, we should not be required in consequence to say who made
and formed them; for without incurring any censure, we may not know who, indeed, gave
them being, and yet assert that not by the Supreme3737 Deity were creatures produced so
useless, so needless, so purposeless,3738 nay more, at times even hurtful, and causing un-
avoidable injuries.
3733 So the ms. and all edd.; but Orelli would change item into iterum, not seeing that the reference is to the
indicated preference of his opponents for the simple truth.
3734 Nescire Hildebrand, with good reason, considers a gloss.
3735 Nihilfor the ms. mihi which makes nonsense of the sentence.
3736 This somewhat wide-spread opinion found an amusing counterpart in the doctrines of Rorarius (men-
tioned by Bayle, Dict. Phil.), who affirmed that the lower animals are gifted with reason and speech, as we are.
3737 Lit., “superior.”
3738 Lit., “tending to no reasons.”
Chapter XLVII.
1050
Chapter XLVII.