CHAP. VII.
The reasons why those things that have been mentioned, which have not the essence of
virtue, have yet by many been mistaken for true virtue.
The first reason may be this, that although they have not the specific and distinguishing
nature and essence of virtue, yet they have something that belongs to the general nature of
virtue. The general nature of true virtue is love. It is expressed both in love of benevolence
and complacence; but primarily in benevolence to persons and beings, and consequently
and secondarily in complacence in virtue, as has been shown. There is something of the
general nature of virtue in those natural affections and principles that have been mentioned,
in both those respects.
In many of these natural affections there appears the tendency and effect of benevolence,
in part. Others have truly a sort of private benevolence, but which in several respects falls
short of the extent of true virtuous benevolence, both in its nature and object. Pity to others
in distress, though not properly of the nature of love, as has been demonstrated, yet has
partly the same influence and effect with benevolence. One effect of true benevolence is for
persons to be uneasy when the objects of it are in distress, and to desire their relief. And
natural pity has the same effect.
Natural gratitude, though not properly called love—because persons may be moved
with a degree of gratitude towards others on certain occasions for whom they have no real
and proper friendship as in the instance of Saul towards David, once and again, after David’s
sparing his life, when he had so fair opportunity to kill him—yet has the like operation and
effect with friendship, in part, for a season, and with regard to so much of the welfare of its
object, as appears a deserved requital of kindness received. And in other instances, it may
have a more general and abiding influence, so as more properly to be called by the name of
love. So that many times men, from natural gratitude, do really with a sort of benevolence,
love those who love them. From this, together with some other natural principles, men may
love their near friends, their own party, their country, &c. The natural disposition there is
to mutual affection between the sexes, often operates by what may properly be called love.
There is oftentimes truly a kind both of benevolence and complacence. As there also is
between parent and children.
Thus these things have something of the general nature of virtue. What they are essen-
tially defective in, is, that they are private in their nature; they do not arise from any temper
of benevolence to being in general, nor have they a tendency to any such effect in their op-
eration. But yet agreeing with virtue in its general nature, they are beautiful within their
own private sphere, i.e. they appear beautiful if we confine our views to that private system,
and while we shut out all other things to which they stand related from our consideration.
If that private system contained the sum of universal existence, their benevolence would
have true beauty; or, in other words, would be beautiful, all things considered; but now it
CHAPTER VII. The reasons of many mistakes
908
CHAPTER VII. The reasons of many mistakes