Chapter IV.
And so, having made these remarks as it were by way of
preface, that I might show in its true colours the injustice of the
public hatred against us, I shall now take my stand on the plea of our
blamelessness; and I shall not only refute the things which are
objected
to us, but I shall
also retort them on the objectors, that in this way all may know that
Christians are free from the very crimes they are so well aware prevail
among themselves, that they may at the same time be put to the blush
for their accusations against us,—accusations I shall not say of
the worst of men against the best, but now, as they will have it,
against those who are only their fellows in sin. We shall reply to the
accusation of all the various crimes we are said to be guilty of in
secret, such as we find them committing in the light of day, and as
being guilty of which we are held to be wicked, senseless, worthy of
punishment, deserving of ridicule. But since, when our truth meets you
successfully at all points, the authority of the laws as a last resort
is set up against it, so that it is either said that their
determinations are absolutely conclusive, or the necessity of obedience
is, however unwillingly, preferred to the truth, I shall first, in this
matter of the laws grapple with you as with their chosen protectors.
Now first, when you sternly lay it down in your sentences, “It is
not lawful for you to exist,” and with unhesitating rigour you
enjoin this to be carried out, you exhibit the violence and unjust
domination of mere tyranny, if you deny the thing to be lawful, simply
on the ground that you wish it to be unlawful, not because it ought to
be. But if you would have it unlawful because it
ought
not to be
lawful, without doubt that should have no permission of law which does
harm; and on this ground, in fact, it is already determined that
whatever is beneficial is legitimate. Well, if I have found what your
law prohibits to be good, as one who has arrived at such a previous
opinion, has it not lost its power to debar me from it, though that
very thing, if it were evil, it would justly forbid to me? If your law
has gone wrong, it is of human origin, I think; it has not fallen from
heaven. Is it wonderful that man should err in making a law, or come to
his senses in rejecting it? Did not the Lacedæmonians amend the
laws of Lycurgus himself, thereby inflicting such pain on their author
that he shut himself up, and doomed himself to death by starvation? Are
you not yourselves every day, in your efforts to illumine the darkness
of antiquity, cutting and hewing with the new axes of imperial
rescripts and edicts, that whole ancient and rugged forest of your
laws? Has not Severus, that most resolute of rulers, but yesterday
repealed the ridiculous Papian laws
81
which compelled
people to have children before the Julian laws allow matrimony to be
contracted, and that though they have the authority of age upon their
side? There were laws, too, in old times, that parties against whom a
decision had been given might be cut in pieces by their creditors;
however, by common consent that cruelty was afterwards erased from the
statutes, and the capital penalty turned into a brand of shame. By
adopting the plan of confiscating a debtor’s goods, it was sought
rather to pour the blood in blushes over his face than to pour it
out. How many laws lie hidden out of sight which still require to
be reformed! For it is neither the number of their years nor the
dignity of their maker that commends them, but simply that they are
just; and therefore, when their injustice is recognized, they are
deservedly condemned, even though they condemn. Why speak we of
them as unjust? nay, if they punish mere names, we may well call them
irrational. But if they punish acts, why in our case do they punish
acts solely on the ground of a name, while in others they must have
them proved not from the name, but from the wrong done? I am a
practiser of incest (so they say); why do they not inquire into it? I
am an infant-killer; why do they not apply the torture to get from me
the truth? I am guilty of crimes against the gods, against the
Cæsars; why am I, who am able to clear myself, not allowed to be
heard on my own behalf? No law forbids the sifting of the crimes which
it prohibits, for a judge never inflicts a righteous vengeance if he is
not well assured that a crime has been committed; nor does a citizen
render a true subjection to the law, if he does not know the nature of
the thing on which the punishment is inflicted. It is not enough that a
law is just, nor that the judge should be convinced of its justice;
those from whom obedience is expected should have that conviction too.
Nay, a law lies under strong suspicions which does not care to have
itself tried and approved: it is a positively wicked law, if, unproved,
it tyrannizes over men.
81
[A reference in
which Kaye sees no reason to doubt that the Apology was written during
the reign under the emperor. See Kaye’s
Tertullian
, p.
49.]