Chapter XV.
The Arians, inasmuch as they assert the Son to be “of another substance,” plainly ac-
knowledge substance in God. The only reason why they avoid the use of this term is that
they will not, as Eusebius of Nicomedia has made it evident, confess Christ to be the true
Son of God.
123. How can the Arians deny the substance of God?1529 How can they suppose that
the word “substance” which is found in many places of Scripture ought to be debarred from
use, when they themselves do yet, by saying that the Son is “ἑτεροούσιος,” that is, of another
substance, admit substance in God?
124. It is not the term itself, then, but its force and consequences, that they shun, because
they will not confess the Son of God to be true [God].1530 For though the process of the divine
generation cannot be comprehended in human language, still the Fathers judged that their
faith might be fitly distinguished by the use of such a term, as against that of “ἑτεροούσιος
,” following the authority of the prophet, who saith: “Who hath stood in the truth (substantia)
of the Lord, and seen His Word?”1531 Arians, therefore, admit the term “substance” when
it is used so as to square with their blasphemy; contrariwise, when it is adopted in accordance
with the pious devotion of the faithful, they reject and dispute against it.
125. What other reason can there be for their unwillingness to have the Son spoken of
260
as “ὁμοούσιος,” of the same substance, with the Father, but that they are unwilling to confess
Him the true Son of God? This is betrayed in the letter of Eusebius of Nicomedia. “If,” writes
he, “we say that the Son is true God and uncreate, then we are in the way to confess Him to
be of one substance (ὁμοούσιος) with the Father.” When this letter had been read before
the Council assembled at Nicæa, the Fathers put this word in their exposition of the Faith,
because they saw that it daunted their adversaries; in order that they might take the sword,
which their opponents had drawn, to smite off the head of those opponents’ own blasphem-
ous heresy.1532
126. Vain, however, is their plea, that they avoid the use of the term, because of the
Sabellians;1533 whereby they betray their own ignorance, for a being is of the same substance
1529 i.e. how can they say there is no Divine Substance, that the use of the term “substance” is illegitimate?
1530 Or to be the true Son of God, Son by nature, not by adoption.
1531 Jer. xxiii. 18.
1532 Cf. 1 Sam. xvii. 51.
1533 The Sabellians reduced the distinction of Persons in the Trinity to a distinction of three different self-
manifestations of one and the same Person, appearing at different times in different aspects or characters, as
“one man in his time plays many parts.” They, therefore, would mean, if they said that the Son was ὁμοούσιος
with the Father, that He was identical with Him. Another perverse use of the term supervened upon the argument
that if the Father and the Son were ὁμοοὐσιοι there must be some οὐσία, identical with neither, but in which
Chapter XV. The Arians, inasmuch as they assert the Son to be “of another substance,” plainly acknowledge substance in God. The only reason why they avoid the use of this term is that they will not, as Eusebius of Nicomedia has made it evident, confess Christ to be the true Son of God.
579
Chapter XV. The Arians, inasmuch as they assert the Son to be “of another…