infinite, how that which is circumscribed by certain proportions, where the idea of quantity
comes in, can come from that which has no size, no proportions, and so on through each
single circumstance of body. But even about this we can say so much: i.e. that not one of
those things which we attribute to body is itself body; neither figure, nor colour, nor weight,
nor extension, nor quantity, nor any other qualifying notion whatever; but every one of
them is a category; it is the combination of them all into a single whole that constitutes body.
Seeing, then, that these several qualifications which complete the particular body are grasped
by thought alone, and not by sense, and that the Deity is a thinking being, what trouble can
it be to such a thinking agent to produce the thinkables whose mutual combination generates
for us the substance of that body? All this discussion, however, lies outside our present
business. The previous question was,—If some souls exist anterior to their bodies, when and
how do they come into existence? and of this question1891, again, the part about the how,
has been left out of our examination and has not been meddled with, as presenting impen-
etrable difficulties. There remains the question of the when of the soul’s commencement of
existence: it follows immediately on that which we have already discussed. For if we were
to grant that the soul has lived previous to its body1892 in some place of resort peculiar to
itself, then we cannot avoid seeing some force in all that fantastic teaching lately discussed,
which would explain the soul’s habitation of the body as a consequence of some vice. Again,
on the other hand, no one who can reflect will imagine an after-birth of the soul, i.e. that it
is younger than the moulding of the body; for every one can see for himself that not one
458
amongst all the things that are inanimate or soulless possesses any power of motion or of
growth; whereas there is no question about that which is bred in the uterus both growing
and moving from place to place. It remains therefore that we must think that the point of
commencement of existence is one and the same for body and soul. Also we affirm that,
just as the earth receives the sapling from the hands of the husbandman and makes a tree
of it, without itself imparting the power of growth to its nursling, but only lending it, when
1891 Reading, as Dr. H. Schmidt conjectures, καὶ τούτου πάλιν, cf. 205 C.
1892 Origen, Gregory’s master in most of his theology, did teach this very thing, the pre-existence of the soul:
nor did he attempt to deny that some degree of transmigration was a necessary accompaniment of such teaching;
only he would adjust the moral meaning of it. Cf. c. Celsum, Lib. iii. 75. “And even if we should treat (i e. med-
ically) those who have caught the folly of the transmigration of souls from doctors who push down a reasoning
nature into any of the unreasoning natures, or even into that which is insensate, how can any say that we shall
not work improvement in their souls by teaching them that the bad do not have allotted to them by way of
punishment that insensate or unreasoning state, but that what is inflicted by God upon the bad, be it pain or
affliction, is only in the way of a very efficacious cure for them? This is the teaching of the wise Christian: he
attempts to teach the simpler of his flock as fathers do the merest infants.” Not the theory itself, but the exagger-
ation of it, is here combated.
852
On the Soul and the Resurrection.