he were himself already in the sphere of darkness which he invented, seeking, and not
finding, how he may escape. But let him say what he will to the seduced and miserable men
by whom he is honored far more highly than Christ, that at this price he may sell to them
such long and sacrilegious fables. Let him say what he will, let him shut up, as it were, in a
sphere, as in a prison, the race of darkness, and let him fasten outside the nature of light, to
which he promised perpetual rest on the extinction of the enemy: behold, the penalty of
light is worse than that of darkness; the penalty of the divine nature is worse than that of
the adverse race. But since although the latter is in the midst of darkness it pertains to its
nature to dwell in darkness; but souls which are the very same thing that God is, cannot be
received, he says, into those peaceful realms, and are alienated from the life and liberty of
the holy light, and are fettered in the aforesaid horrible sphere: whence he says, "Those
souls shall adhere to the things that they have loved, having been left in the same sphere of
darkness, bringing this upon themselves by their own deserts." Is not this assuredly free
voluntary choice? See how insanely he ignores what he says, and by making self-contradictory
statements wages a worse war against himself than against the God of the race of darkness
itself. Accordingly, if the souls of light are damned, because they loved darkness, the race
of darkness, which loved light, is unjustly damned. And the race of darkness indeed loved
light from the beginning, violently, it may be, but yet so as to wish for its possession, not its
extinction: but the nature of light wished to extinguish in war the darkness; therefore when
vanquished it loved darkness. Choose which you will: whether it was compelled by necessity
to love darkness, or seduced by free will. If by necessity, wherefore is it damned? if by free
will, wherefore is the nature of God involved in so great iniquity? If the nature of God was
compelled by necessity to love darkness, it did not vanquish, but was vanquished: if by free
will, why do the wretches hesitate any longer to attribute the will to sin to the nature which
God made out of nothing, lest they should thereby attribute it to the light which He begat?
635
Manichæan Blasphemies Concerning the Nature of God.