1862-67] TWOFOLD MORAL WITNESS 233
the other, and that there is an obligation on us to choose
the higher. The facts that we can choose ; that there is
a distinction of better and worse ; that we are bound to
choose the better; are ultimate facts that we cannot get
beyond. And we have also the external witness of which
I have spoken in its strongest form ; the consciousness of
the race, shown in its laws and languages ; the testimony
of the laws of the universe, since we find by experience that
a persistent choice of the better course tends to the well-
being of the whole, and a persistent choice of the lower
alternative leads to suffering and destruction.
Your difficulty, as I understand, lies, however, in my
second point whether we have the witness of the con-
sciousness of the race ; whether there is not more disagree-
ment than agreement in the intuitions of men on moral
questions. I think you will come to see, the more you
reflect on it, that the agreement infinitely transcends the
disagreement ; as might be expected, where the agreement
rests on the common nature of men and their common
relation to God and each other; and the disagreement
springs from the different stages of development in the
individual or people. The three great facts I have spoken
of above find their witness in the fact, that all nations have
laws, and think that those who disobey them ought to be
punished ; and all languages have words answering to
"right" and " wrong " and " ought." Of course the
moral faculty does not act alone, but in conjunction with
all the faculties of the man, and is susceptible of cultiva-
tion, just as they are. It does not affect our certainty of
scientific results to know that there are savages who
cannot count beyond ten ; or our perception of the
beauty of music to know that there are others whose
highest idea of harmony is a discordant howl, and to
whom our concerted music would be mere unintelligible
confusion. But that the primary intuitions of right and
wrong are to be found in all men, we have plenty of
testimony besides what I have quoted. Missionaries Dr.
Livingstone, for instance tell us that their hearers allow