could not but deny this. I therefore reminded him that he had endured such persecution
that his church had been razed to the foundations. By these instances I laboured to persuade
him, if possible, to give up affirming that the suffering of persecution is the most infallible
mark of Christian righteousness.
8. He also related that, in the infancy of their schism, his predecessors, being anxious
to devise some way of hushing up the fault of Cæcilianus, lest a schism should take place,
had appointed over the people belonging to his communion in Carthage an interim bishop
288
before Majorinus was ordained in opposition to Cæcilianus. He alleged that this interim
bishop was murdered in his own meeting house by our party. This, I confess, I had never
heard before, though so many charges brought by them against us have been refuted and
disproved, while by us greater and more numerous crimes have been alleged against them.
After having narrated this story, he began again to insist on my answering whether in this
case I thought the murderer or the victim the more righteous man; as if he had already
proved that the event had taken place as he had stated. I therefore said that we must first
ascertain the truth of the story, for we ought not to believe without examination all that is
said: and that even were it true, it was possible either that both were equally bad, or that one
who was bad had caused the death of another yet worse than himself. For, in truth, it is
possible that his guilt is more heinous who rebaptizes the whole man than his who kills the
body only.
9. After this there was no occasion for the question which he afterwards put to me. He
affirmed that even a bad man should not be killed by Christians and righteous men; as if
we called those who in the Catholic Church do such things righteous men: a statement,
moreover, which it is more easy for them to affirm than to prove to us, so long as they
themselves, with few exceptions, bishops, presbyters, and clergy of all kinds, go on gathering
mobs of most infatuated men, and causing, wherever they are able, so many violent massacres,
and devastations to the injury not of Catholics only, but sometimes even of their own par-
tisans. In spite of these facts, Fortunius, affecting ignorance of the most villanous doings,
which were better known by him than by me, insisted upon my giving an example of a
righteous man putting even a bad man to death. This was, of course, not relevant to the
matter in hand; for I conceded that wherever such crimes were committed by men having
the name of Christians, they were not the actions of good men. Nevertheless, in order to
show him what was the true question before us, I answered by inquiring whether Elijah
seemed to him to be a righteous man; to which he could not but assent. Thereupon I re-
minded him how many false prophets Elijah slew with his own hand.1653 He saw plainly
herein, as indeed he could not but see, that such things were then lawful to righteous men.
For they did these things as prophets guided by the Spirit and sanctioned by the authority
1653 1 Kings xviii. 40.
651
To Eleusius, Glorius, and the Two Felixes