his ability; unless the Will from which they proceed be truly good and virtuous, they can be
of no avail or weight whatsoever in a moral respect. That which is not truly virtuous is, in
God’s sight, good for nothing: and so can be of no value, or influence, in his account, to
make up for any moral defect. For nothing can counterbalance evil, but good. If evil be in
one scale, and we put a great deal into the other of sincere and earnest Desires, and many
and great Endeavours; yet, if there be no real goodness in all, there is no weight in it; and so
it does nothing towards balancing the real weight, which is in the opposite scale. It is only
like subtracting a thousand noughts from before a real number, which leaves the sum just
as it was.
Indeed such Endeavours may have a negatively good influence. Those things, which
have no positive virtue, have no positive moral influence; yet they may be an occasion of
persons avoiding some positive evils. As if a man were in the water with a neighbor to whom
he had ill will, and who could not swim, holding him by his hand; this neighbor was much
in debt to him,—the man is tempted to let him sink and drown—but refuses to comply with
the temptation; not from love to his neighbor, but from the love of money, and because by
his drowning he should lose his debt; that which he does in preserving his neighbor from
drowning, is nothing good in the sight of God: yet hereby he avoids the greater guilt that
would have been contracted, if he had designedly let his neighbor sink and perish. But when
Arminians, in their disputes with Calvinists, insist so much on sincere Desires and Endeav-
ours, as what must excuse men, must be accepted of God, &c. it is manifest they have respect
to some positive moral weight or influence of those Desires and Endeavours. Accepting,
53
justifying, or excusing on the account of sincere Endeavours, (as they are called,) and men
doing what they can, &c. has relation to some moral value, something that is accepts as
good, and as such, countervailing some defect.
But there is a great and unknown deceit, arising from the ambiguity of the phrase, sincere
Endeavours. Indeed there is a vast indistinctness and unfixedness in most, or at least very
many of the terms used to express things pertaining to moral and spiritual matters. Whence
arise innumerable mistakes, strong prejudices, inextricable confusion, and endless contro-
versy.—The word sincere is most commonly used to signify something that is good: men
are habituated to understand by it the same as honest and upright; which terms excite an
idea of something good in the strictest and highest sense; good in the sight of him, who sees
not only the outward appearance, but the heart. And, therefore, men think that if a person
be sincere, he will certainly be accepted. If it be said that any one is sincere in his Endeavours,
this suggests, that his heart is good, that there is no defect of duty, as to virtuous inclination;
he honestly and uprightly desires and endeavours to do as he is required; and this leads them
to suppose, that it would be very hard and unreasonable to punish him, only because he is
unsuccessful in his Endeavours, the thing endeavored after being beyond his
656
SECTION V. That Sincerity of Desires and Endeavours, which is supposed…