73
Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(About 160 years having elapsed, pp. 59, 61.)
If the First Epistle to the Corinthians was written a.d. 57, and if our author speaks with
designed precision, and not in round numbers, the date of this treatise should be a.d. 217—a
date which I should prefer to accept. Bishop Kaye, 696 however, instances capp. 7 and 9 in
the Ad Nationes as proving his disposition to give his numbers in loose rhetoric, and not
with arithmetical accuracy. Pamelius, on the other hand, gives a.d. 213.
On the general subject Kaye bids us read cap. 3, with cap. 14, to grasp the argument of
our enthusiast. 697 In few words, our author holds that St. Paul condescends to human in-
firmity in permitting any marriage whatever, pointing to a better way. 698 The apostle
himself says, “The time is short;” but a hundred and sixty years have passed since then, and
why may not the Spirit of truth and righteousness now, after so long a time, be given to
animate the adult Church to that which is pronounced the better way in Scripture itself?
Our author seems struggling here, according to my view, with his own rule of prescrip-
tion. He would free the doctrine from the charge of novelty by pointing it out in the Scripture
of a hundred and sixty years before. But how instinctively the Church ruled against this
sophistry, condemning in advance that whole system of “development” which a modern
Tertullian defends on grounds quite as specious, under a Montanistic subjection that makes
a Priscilla of the Roman pontiff. Let me commend the reader to the remarks upon Tertullian
of the “judicious Hooker,” in book ii. capp. v. 5, 6; also book iv. cap. vii. 4, 5, and elsewhere.
II.
(Abrogated indulgence (comp. capp. 2 and 3), p. 70.)
Poor Tertullian is at war with himself in all the works which he indites against Catholic
orthodoxy. In the tract De Exhort. Castitatis he gives one construction to 1 Cor. ix. 5, which
in this he explains away; 699 and now he patches up his conclusion by referring to his
Montanistic “Paraclete.” In fighting Marcion, how thoroughly he agrees with Clement of
Alexandria as to the sanctity of marriage. In the second epistle to his wife, how beautiful
his tribute to the married state, blessed by the Church, and enjoyed in chastity. But here
700 how fanatically he would make out that marriage is but tolerated adultery! From Tertul-
lian himself we may prove the marriage of the clergy, and that ( de Exhort. Cast., last chapter)
696 P. 40, Kaye’s Tertullian.
697 P. 24, Kaye’s Tertullian.
698 Comp. Bacon, Essays, No. viii., Of Marriage and Single Life.
699 Comp. Ex. Cast., cap. viii. p. 55, supra, with the Monogam., cap. viii. p. 65, supra.
700 Comp. Apparel of Women, ii. cap. ix. p. 23, supra.
Elucidations.
167
Elucidations.