37. But if souls were, as is said, the Lord’s children, and begotten by3659 the Supreme
Power, nothing would have been wanting to make them perfect, as they would have been
born with the most perfect excellence: they would all have had one mind, and been of one
accord; they would always dwell in the royal palace; and would not, passing by the seats of
bliss in which they had learned and kept in mind the noblest teachings, rashly seek these
regions of earth, that3660 they might live enclosed in gloomy bodies amid phlegm and blood,
among these bags of filth and most disgusting3661 vessels of urine. But, an opponent will
say, it was necessary that these parts too should be peopled, and therefore Almighty God
sent souls hither to form some colonies, as it were. And of what use are men to the world,
and on account of what are they necessary,3662 so that they may not be believed to have
been destined to live here and be the tenants of an earthly body for no purpose? They have
a share, my opponent says, in perfecting the completeness of this immense mass, and without
their addition this whole universe is incomplete and imperfect. What then? If there were
not men, would the world cease to discharge its functions? would the stars not go through
their changes? would there not be summers and winters? would the blasts of the winds be
lulled? and from the clouds gathered and hanging overhead would not the showers come
down upon the earth to temper droughts? But now3663 all things must go on in their own
courses, and not give up following the arrangement established by nature, even if there
should be no name of man heard in the world, and this earth should be still with the silence
of an unpeopled desert. How then is it alleged that it was necessary that an inhabitant should
be given to these regions, since it is clear that by man comes nothing to aid in perfecting
the world, and that all his exertions regard his private convenience always, and never cease
to aim at his own advantage?
3659 Lit., “a generation of.”
3660 Canterus, Elmenhorst, Oberthür, and Orelli omit ut, which is retained as above by the rest.
3661 Lit., “obscene.”
3662 Elmenhorst endeavours to show that Arnobius coincides in this argument with the Epicureans, by
quoting Lucr. v. 165 sqq. and Lact. vii. 5, where the Epicurean argument is brought forward, What profit has
God in man, that He should have created him? In doing this, it seems not to have been observed that the question
asked by Arnobius is a very different one: What place has man in the world, that God should be supposed to
have sent him to fill it?
3663 i.e., so far from this being the case.
Chapter XXXVII.
1039
Chapter XXXVII.