II. A Refutation of This Dogma on the Ground of Familiar Human Analogies.
How, shall we bear with these men who assert that all those wise, and consequently also
noble, constructions (in the universe) are only the works of common chance? those objects,
I mean, of which each taken by itself as it is made, and the whole system collectively, were
seen to be good by Him by whose command they came into existence. For, as it is said, “God
saw everything that He had made, and, behold, it was very good.”647 But truly these men
do not reflect on648 the analogies even of small familiar things which might come under
their observation at any time, and from which they might learn that no object of any utility,
and fitted to be serviceable, is made without design or by mere chance, but is wrought by
skill of hand, and is contrived so as to meet its proper use. And when the object falls out of
service and becomes useless, then it also begins to break up indeterminately, and to decom-
pose and dissipate its materials in every casual and unregulated way, just as the wisdom by
which it was skilfully constructed at first no longer controls and maintains it. For a cloak,
for example, cannot be made without the weaver, as if the warp could be set aright and the
woof could be entwined with it by their own spontaneous action; while, on the other hand,
if it is once worn out, its tattered rags are flung aside. Again, when a house or a city is built,
it does not take on its stones, as if some of them placed themselves spontaneously upon the
foundations, and others lifted themselves up on the several layers, but the builder carefully
disposes the skilfully prepared stones in their proper positions; while if the structure happens
once to give way, the stones are separated and cast down and scattered about. And so, too,
when a ship is built, the keel does not lay itself, neither does the mast erect itself in the centre,
nor do all the other timbers take up their positions casually and by their own motion. Nor,
again, do the so-called hundred beams in the wain fit themselves spontaneously to the vacant
spaces they severally light on. But the carpenter in both cases puts the materials together in
the right way and at the right time.649 And if the ship goes to sea and is wrecked, or if the
wain drives along on land and is shattered, their timbers are broken up and cast abroad
anywhere,—those of the former by the waves, and those of the latter by the violence of the
impetus. In like manner, then, we might with all propriety say also to these men, that those
atoms of theirs, which remain idle and unmanipulated and useless, are introduced vainly.
Let them, accordingly, seek for themselves to see into what is beyond the reach of sight, and
conceive what is beyond the range of conception;650 unlike him who in these terms confesses
647 Gen. i. 31.
648 The text is, ἀλλ᾽ οὐδὲ ἀπὸ τῶν μικρῶν τῶν συνήθων καὶ παρὰ πόδας νουθετούντων, etc. We adopt Viger’s
suggestions and read νουθετοῦνται.
649 The text is, ἑκατέρας συνεκόμισε καιριον, for which Viger proposes εἰς τὸν ἑκατέρας, etc.
650 The text gives, ὁράτωσαν γὰρ τὰς ἀθεάτους ἐκεῖνοι, καὶ τὰς ἀνοήτους νοείτωσαν, οὐχ ὁμοίως ἐκείνῳ,
etc. The passage seems corrupt. Some supply φύσεις as the subject intended in the ἀθεάτους and ἀνοήτους; but
that leaves the connection still obscure. Viger would read, with one ms., ἀθέτους instead of ἀθάετους, and makes
A Refutation of This Dogma on the Ground of Familiar Human Analogies.
193
A Refutation of This Dogma on the Ground of Familiar Human Analogies.