was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. The same was in the
beginning with God. All things were made by Him, and without Him was not anything
made,"369 and such passages, which they agree to, without understanding them? Where
did John see this, or did he ever hear it from the Lord Himself? In whatever way John learned
this, those who narrate the nativity may have learned also. Again, how do they know that
the Lord said, "Who is my mother, and who are my brethren?" If on the authority of the
evangelist, why do they not also believe that the mother and the brethren of Christ were
seeking for Him? They believe that Christ said these words, which they misunderstand,
while they deny a fact resting on the same authority. Once more, if Matthew could not
know that Christ was born, because he knew Him only in His manhood, how could
Manichæus, who lived so long after, know that He was not born? They will say that
Manichæus knew this from the Holy Spirit which was in him. Certainly the Holy Spirit
would make him speak the truth. But why not rather believe what Christ’s own disciples
tell us, who were personally acquainted with Him, and who not only had the gift of inspiration
to supply defects in their knowledge, but in a purely natural way obtained information of
the birth of Christ, and of His descent, when the event was fresh in memory? And yet he
dares to call the apostles deaf and blind. Why were you not deaf and blind, to prevent you
from learning such profane nonsense, and dumb too, to prevent you from uttering it?
————————————
369 John i. 1-5.
296
The genealogical question is again taken up and argued on both sides.