19. ἐξ ἡμ. ἐξ.] Ex nobis prodierunt (exierunt) V., They went out from us they proceeded from our midst. They belonged at first to our outward communion and shared all our privileges. Till the moment of separation they were undistinguishable from the rest of the Christian society; but they were not of us, they did not draw their life from our life (c. i. 3) and so form living members of the body. Comp. Heb. vi. 4 ff.
The change in the position of ἐξ ἡμῶν in the successive clauses varies the emphasis: 'From us, it is true, they went out, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us really...' For εἶναι ἐκ see v. 16 note.
The phrase ἐξελθεῖν ἐξ may describe either removal (Apoc. xviii. 4; John viii. 59) or origin (Apoc. ix. 3; xiv. 13 ff.; xix. 5, 21; John iv. 30). The correspondence with οὐκ ἦσαν ἐξ ἡμῶν decides here in favour of the latter sense (comp. Acts xx. 30), though it necessarily leads to the other. This trait in the Antichrists indicates one ground of their influence. They professed to speak with the voice of the Christian Body. Διὰ τί ἀπὸ τῶν τοῦ Κυρίου μαθητῶν οἱ ἀντίχριστοι; ἵν' ἔχομεν τὸ πιστὸν τοῖς πλανωμένοις κομίζειν ὡς ἀπὸ τῶν μαθητῶν ὄντες... (Theophlet.)
εἰ γὰρ...] If they had in the truest sense shared our life, the life would have gone forward to its fruitful consummation (μεμενήκεισαν ἂν permansissent utique V.). The fact of separation revealed the imperfection of their fellowship. The words will not admit of any theoretical deductions. The test of experience is laid down as final. Non audio quid sonet, Augustine says, sed video quid vivat. Opera loquuntur; et verba requirimus?
Here, looking upon the manifest apostasy, St John denies the truth of the life; from another point of sight, in regard to the uncertain future, the
ἡμῶν ἦσαν, μεμενήκεισαν ἂν μεθ' ἡμῶν· ἀλλ' ἵνα φανερωlife is presented as real, but liable to an abrupt close (John xv. 1 ff.). The two views are perfectly harmonious. The end of life is fruitfulness. The life which is barren or worse than barren is not life and yet potentially it was life.
Thus Augustine can say truly in reference to the actual Church: Si antequam exirent non erant ex nobis, multi intus sunt, non exierunt, et tamen Antichristi sunt. And again: Sic sunt in corpore Christi quomodo humores mali. Compare also the striking language of Ignatius, ad Trall. 11 οὗτοι οὐκ εἰσὶ φυτεία πατρὸς ἀλλ' ἔγνονα κατηρομένα. πᾶσα δέ, φησὶν ὁ κύριος, φυτεία ἦν οὐκ ἐφύτευσεν ὁ πατήρ μου ὁ ἐπουράνιος ἐκριζωθήτω. εἰ γὰρ ἦσαν τοῦ πατρὸς κλάδοι οὐκ ἂν ἦσαν ἐχθροὶ τοῦ σταυροῦ τοῦ Χριστοῦ ἀλλὰ τῶν ἀποκτείνων τῶν τῆς δόξης κύριον.
It may be added that γὰρ, for, is very rarely used in the Epistles; c. iv. 20; v. 3; 2 John 11; 3 John 3, 7. As distinguished from ὅτι, because, it will be seen that γὰρ expresses a reason or explanation alleged (subjective), while ὅτι marks a distinct fact (objective) which is itself an adequate cause or explanation of that with which it is connected. Comp. c. v. 3, 4; John ii. 25; iii. 16—21; iii. 23 f.; ix. 22, &c.
μεθ' ἡμῶν] It might have been expected that St John would have written ἐν ἡμῖν, according to his characteristic usage which is all but universal in his Epistles; but the thought is not of absolute unity in one body but of personal fellowship one with another: John xiv. 16; Luke xxiv. 29.
ἀλλ' ἵνα...] but they went out (or this separation came to pass) that they may be made manifest (ut manifesti sint [manifestarentur] V.), that they all are not of us i.e. that none of them are of us. For this ellipse see John i. 8; ix. 3; xiii. 18; xiv.
31; xv. 25. The departure of these false teachers after a temporary sojourn in the Christian society was brought about that they might be shewn in their true character, and so seen to be not of it. The last clause is rather irregular in form. The πάντες is inserted as it were by an afterthought; 'they went out that they may be made manifest that they are not, no not in any case, however fair their pretensions may be, of us.'
The separation of these teachers from the Christian Body was, without exception, a decisive proof that they did not belong truly to it. The clear revelation of their character was a divine provision for the avoidance of further evil. By 'going out' they neutralised the influence which they would otherwise have exercised. Comp. 1 Cor. xi. 19.
When the πᾶς is separated by the verb from the οὐ the negation according to the usage of the New Testament, is always universal (all...not), and not partial (not all). Comp. c. 21; iii. 15; Apoc. xxii. 3; Matt. xxiv. 22 (οὐ...πᾶς); Luke i. 37 (οὐ πᾶς); Acts x. 15; Rom. iii. 20 (οὐ...πᾶς); Gal. ii. 16 (οὐ...πᾶς); Eph. v. 5; and in dependent negations, John iii. 16 (πᾶς...μὴ); vi. 39 (πᾶς...μὴ); xii. 46 (id.); 1 Cor. i. 29 (μὴ...πᾶς); Eph. iv. 29 (πᾶς...μὴ). Comp. Apoc. xxi. 27 (οὐ μὴ...πᾶς).
On the other hand see Matt. vii. 21; Rom. ix. 6; 1 Cor. x. 23; xv. 39 (οὐ πᾶς).
In the face of this usage it is impossible to translate the words 'that they may be made manifest themselves, and that it may be made manifest in them that not all who are outwardly united with the Church are of us, in true fellowship with Christ.'
For φανερ. ὅτι οὐκ εἰσίν compare 2 Cor. iii. 3 φανερούμενοι ὅτι ἐστέ.
{"canonical_mapping_status":"native_coordinates_only; no canonical mapping inferred","footnote_boundary_status":"whole_native_row_preserved; no independent-note segmentation or note-count claim","html_tags":{"b":3,"i":5,"p":16},"id":"sqlite3:280aa5b578b17d3dd9b56ec9d0f065a1b154f8e7c2e467799a3faacf064f545f:commentaries:30","native_body_column":"text","native_module_metadata":{"$context_sha256":"c696c188a5bc382915c66fa78834b5c544a6f2c23fc77ed893080f26b218c382"},"native_reference":{"book_number":690,"chapter_number_from":2,"chapter_number_to":2,"verse_number_from":19,"verse_number_to":19},"native_rowid":30,"native_table":"commentaries","projection":"HTML character data with explicit block newlines; no text-node deletion or whitespace folding; original HTML retained","public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"native-verse-keyed-module-record","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_family_classification":"sermonindex","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"d0b5e6f8113710b2381cec59fa8bafb5c9a5e51efd079ede2c68383e6c090143"},"source_html_sha256":"d0b5e6f8113710b2381cec59fa8bafb5c9a5e51efd079ede2c68383e6c090143","source_locator":{"$context_sha256":"2a8c06bf10237edc9987935a6bf5ce2f9c1b3d30a1a066b4a90d1c5c99739cf5"},"source_origin_path":"SI-WESTCOTT.commentaries.SQLite3","source_sha256":"280aa5b578b17d3dd9b56ec9d0f065a1b154f8e7c2e467799a3faacf064f545f"}