160 ON THE TRINITY. [BOOK V.
the working of miracles ; to another prophecy; to another the
discerning of spirits ; to another divers kinds of tongues ; to
another the interpretation of tongues : but all these worketh
that one and the self-same Spirit, dividing to every man
severally as He will
;
" certainly as God—for who can work
such great things but God ?—but " it is the same God which
worketh all in all." ^ For if we are asked point by point
concerning the Holy Spirit, we answer most truly that He is
God ; and with the Father and the Son together He is one
God. Therefore, God is spoken of as one beginning in respect
to the creature, not as two or three beginnings.
Chap. xiv.—The Father and the Son the only beginning of the Holy Spirit.
15. But in their mutual relation to one another in the
Trinity itself, if the begetter is a beginning in relation to that
which he becfets, the Father is a beojinningj in relation to the
Son, because He begets Him ; but whether the Father is also
a beginning in relation to the Holy Spirit, since it is said,
"He proceeds from the Father," is no small question. Because,
if it is so. He will not only be a beginning to that thingwhich
He begets or makes, but also to that which He gives. And
here, too, that question comes to light, as it can, which is wont
to trouble many. Why the Holy Spirit is not also a son, since
He, too, comes forth from the Father, as it is read in the Gospel."^
For the Spirit came forth, not as born, but as given ; and so
He is not called a son, because He was neither born, as the
Only-begotten, nor made, so that by the grace of God He
might be born into adoption, as we are. For that which is
born of the Father, is referred to the Father only when called
Son, and so the Son is the Son of the Father, and not also our
Son ; but that which is given is referred both to Him who gave,
and to those towhom He gave ; and so the Holy Spirit is not
only the Spirit of the Father and of the Son who gave Him,
but He is also called ours, who have received Him : as " The
salvation of the Lord," ^ who gives salvation, is said also to be
our salvation, who have received it. Therefore, the Spirit is
both the Spirit of God who gave Him, and ours who have
received Him. Not, indeed, that spirit of ours by which we
I 1 Cor. xii. 6-11. * John xv. 26. ^ Ps. iii. 8.