Chapter 10.—The Necessity for Perspicuity of Style.
24. Now a strong desire for clearness sometimes leads to neglect of the more polished
forms of speech, and indifference about what sounds well, compared with what clearly ex-
presses and conveys the meaning intended. Whence a certain author, when dealing with
speech of this kind, says that there is in it “a kind of careful negligence.”1949 Yet while taking
away ornament, it does not bring in vulgarity of speech; though good teachers have, or ought
to have, so great an anxiety about teaching that they will employ a word which cannot be
made pure Latin without becoming obscure or ambiguous, but which when used according
to the vulgar idiom is neither ambiguous nor obscure, not in the way the learned, but rather
in the way the unlearned employ it. For if our translators did not shrink from saying, “Non
congregabo conventicula eorum de sanguinibus,”1950 because they felt that it was important
for the sense to put a word here in the plural which in Latin is only used in the singular;
why should a teacher of godliness who is addressing an unlearned audience shrink from
using ossum instead of os, if he fear that the latter might be taken not as the singular of ossa,
but as the singular of ora, seeing that African ears have no quick perception of the shortness
or length of vowels? And what advantage is there in purity of speech which does not lead
to understanding in the hearer, seeing that there is no use at all in speaking, if they do not
understand us for whose sake we speak? He, therefore, who teaches will avoid all words
that do not teach; and if instead of them he can find words which are at once pure and intel-
ligible, he will take these by preference; if, however, he cannot, either because there are no
such words, or because they do not at the time occur to him, he will use words that are not
quite pure, if only the substance of his thought be conveyed and apprehended in its integrity.
25. And this must be insisted on as necessary to our being understood, not only in
conversations, whether with one person or with several, but much more in the case of a
speech delivered in public: for in conversation any one has the power of asking a question;
but when all are silent that one may be heard, and all faces are turned attentively upon him,
it is neither customary nor decorous for a person to ask a question about what he does not
understand; and on this account the speaker ought to be especially careful to give assistance
to those who cannot ask it. Now a crowd anxious for instruction generally shows by its
movements if it understands what is said; and until some indication of this sort be given,
the subject discussed ought to be turned over and over, and put in every shape and form
and variety of expression, a thing which cannot be done by men who are repeating words
prepared beforehand and committed to memory. As soon, however, as the speaker has as-
certained that what he says is understood, he ought either to bring his address to a close, or
1949 Cicero, Orator. 23: “Quædam etiam negligentia est diligens.”
1950 “I shall not assemble their assemblies of blood,” Ps. xvi. 4. (Vulgate.) “Their drink-offerings of blood
will I not offer.” (A.V.)
The Necessity for Perspicuity of Style.
1320
The Necessity for Perspicuity of Style.