and you will find that “justice,”—whatever you mean by that,—records in your own words175
a verdict against us.
It is easy also to find mud in his words after that to cast upon this execrable teaching.
For the other horn of his dilemma partakes in the same mental delusion; he says, “or else
you first allow one single causeless being, and then marking this out by an act of generation
into Father and Son, you declare that this non-generated being came into existence by means
of itself.” What is this new and marvellous story? How is one begotten by oneself, having
oneself for father, and becoming one’s own son? What dizziness and delusion is here? It is
like supposing the roof to be turning down below one’s feet, and the floor above one’s head;
it is like the mental state of one with his senses stupified with drink, who shouts out persist-
ently that the ground does not stand still beneath, and that the walls are disappearing, and
that everything he sees is whirling round and will not keep still. Perhaps our pamphleteer
had such a tumult in his soul when he wrote; if so, we must pity him rather than abhor him.
For who is so out of hearing of our divine doctrine, who is so far from the mysteries of the
Church, as to accept such a view as this to the detriment of the Faith. Rather, it is hardly
enough to say, that no one ever dreamed of such an absurdity to its detriment. Why, in the
81
case of human nature, or any other entity falling within the grasp of the senses who, when
he hears of a community of substance, dreams either that all things that are compared to-
gether on the ground of substance are without a cause or beginning, or that something
comes into existence out of itself, at once producing and being produced by itself?
The first man, and the man born from him, received their being in a different way; the
latter by copulation, the former from the moulding of Christ Himself; and yet, though they
are thus believed to be two, they are inseparable in the definition of their being, and are not
considered as two beings, without beginning or cause, running parallel to each other; nor
can the existing one be said to be generated by the existing one, or the two be ever thought
of as one in the monstrous sense that each is his own father, and his own son; but it is because
the one and the other was a man that the two have the same definition of being; each was
mortal, reasoning, capable of intuition and of science. If, then, the idea of humanity in Adam
and Abel does not vary with the difference of their origin, neither the order nor the manner
of their coming into existence making any difference in their nature, which is the same in
both, according to the testimony of every one in his senses, and no one, not greatly needing
treatment for insanity, would deny it; what necessity is there that against the divine nature
we should admit this strange thought? Having heard of Father and Son from the Truth, we
175 your own words, i.e. not ours, as you say. The Codex of Turin has τοῖς ἡμετέροις, and ἡμῖν above: but
Oehler has wisely followed that of Venice. Eunomius had said of Basil’s party (§34) ‘justice records in your own
words a verdict against yourselves.’ ‘No,’ Gregory answers; ‘your words (interpreting our doctrine) alone lend
themselves to that.’ But to change καθ᾽ ἡμῶν of the Codd. also to καθ᾽ ὑμῶν would supply a still better sense.
154
The Passage where he attacks the μ , and the contention in answer…