Chapter XVIII.—Answer to a Psychical Objection.
“But these (passages),” says (our opponent), “will pertain to the interdiction of all im-
modesty, and the enforcing of all modesty, yet without prejudice to the place of pardon;
which (pardon) is not forthwith quite denied when sins are condemned, since the time of
the pardon is concurrent with the condemnation which it excludes.”
This piece of shrewdness on the part of the Psychics was (naturally) sequent; and accord-
ingly we have reserved for this place the cautions which, even in the times of antiquity, were
openly taken with a view to the refusing of ecclesiastical communion to cases of this kind.
For even in the Proverbs, which we call Parœmiæ, Solomon specially (treats) of the
adulterer (as being) nowhere admissible to expiation. “But the adulterer,” he says, “through
indigence of senses acquireth perdition to his own soul; sustaineth dolors and disgraces.
His ignominy, moreover, shall not be wiped away for the age. For indignation, full of jeal-
ousy, will not spare the man in the day of judgment.” 912 If you think this said about a
heathen, at all events about believers you have already heard (it said) through Isaiah: “Go
out from the midst of them, and be separate, and touch not the impure.” 913 You have at
the very outset of the Psalms, “Blessed the man who hath not gone astray in the counsel of
the impious, nor stood in the way of sinners, and sat in the state-chair of pestilence;” 914
whose voice, 915 withal, (is heard) subsequently: “I have not sat with the conclave of vanity;
and with them who act iniquitously will I not enter”—this (has to do with “ the church” of
such as act ill—“and with the impious will I not sit;” 916 and, “I will wash with the innocent
mine hands, and Thine altar will I surround, Lord” 917—as being “a host in himself”—inas-
much as indeed “With an holy (man), holy Thou wilt be; and with an innocent man, innocent
Thou wilt be; and with an elect, elect Thou wilt be; and with a perverse, perverse Thou wilt
be.” 918 And elsewhere: “But to the sinner saith the Lord, Why expoundest thou my right-
eous acts, and takest up my testament through thy mouth? If thou sawest a thief, thou
rannest with him; and with adulterers thy portion thou madest.” 919 Deriving his instruc-
tions, therefore, from hence, the apostle too says: “I wrote to you in the Epistle, not to be
mingled up with fornicators: not, of course, with the fornicators of this world”—and so
forth—“else it behoved you to go out from the world. But now I write to you, if any is named
912 Prov. vi. 32–34.
913 Isa. lii. 11, quoted in 2 Cor. vi. 17.
914 Ps. i. 1 in LXX.
915 i.e., the voice of this “blessed man,” this true “Asher.”
916 Ps. xxvi. 4, 5 (in LXX. xxv. 4, 5).
917 Ps. xxvi. (xxv. in LXX.) 6, not quite exactly.
918 Ps. xviii. 25, 26 (in LXX. Ps. xviii. 26, 27), nearly.
919 Ps. l. (xlix. in LXX.) 16, 18.
Answer to a Psychical Objection.
212
Answer to a Psychical Objection.