that there was some sort of a plot on foot, and that the plotters were Christians. The question
then arose what course should be pursued in the matter. And this question may well have
caused the calling together of a number of counsellors and the consultation of the oracle of
Apollo of which Lactantius tells us. Galerius naturally wished to exterminate the Christians
as a whole, knowing their universal hostility to him; but Diocletian just as naturally wished
to punish only such as were concerned in the plot, and was by no means convinced that the
Christians as a whole were engaged in it. The decision which was reached, and which is ex-
hibited in the edict of the 24th of February, 303 seems to confirm in a remarkable manner
the theory which has been presented. Instead of issuing an edict against Christians in gen-
eral, Diocletian directs his blows solely against Christians in governmental circles,—public
officials and servants in official families (cf. the interpretation of the edict given above in
Bk. VIII. chap. 2, note 6). This is certainly not the procedure of an emperor who is persecuting
on religious grounds. The church officers should in that case have been first attacked as they
had been by Decius and Valerian. The singling out of Christians in official circles—and the
low as well as the high ones, the servants as well as the masters—is a clear indication that
the motive was political, not religious. Moreover, that the edict was drawn in such mild
terms is a confirmation of this. These men were certainly not all guilty, and it was not neces-
sary to put them all to death. It was necessary to put an end to the plot in the most expeditious
and complete way. The plotters should be shown that their plot was discovered, and the
whole thing should be broken up by causing some of them to renounce their faith, by de-
grading and depriving of citizenship all that would not renounce it. It was a very shrewd
move. Executions would but have increased the rebellious spirit and caused the plot to
spread. But Diocletian was well aware that any one that renounced his faith would lose caste
with his fellow-Christians, and even if he had been a plotter in the past, he could never hope
400
to gain anything in the future from the accession of a Christian emperor. He was careful
moreover to provide against any danger from those who refused to renounce their faith, by
putting them into a position where it would be impossible for them to accomplish anything
in that line in the future. He knew that a plot which had no support within official circles
would be of no account and was not to be feared. The action, based on the grounds given,
was worthy of Diocletian’s genius; explained in any other way it becomes, in my opinion,
meaningless. A further confirmation of the view which has been presented is found in the
silence of Lactantius and Eusebius. The former was in Nicomedia, and cannot have failed
to know the ostensible if not the true cause of the great persecution. Diocletian cannot have
taken such a step without giving some reason for it, and doubtless that reason was stated in
the preambles of his edicts, as is the case in the edicts of other emperors; but as it happens,
while we know the substance of all the edicts, not a single preamble has been preserved.
May it not be possible that the Christians, who preserved the terms of the edicts, found the
preambles distasteful because derogatory to some of themselves and yet unfortunately not
1022
On Bk. VIII. chap. 2, § 4 (note 3, continued). The Causes of the Diocletian…