having no inclination to any thing that is good. (Guide to Christ; p. 68. see also Benef. of the
Gos. p. 130. a. b.) That they utterly neglect the end they were made for, and make it their
business to serve themselves; they care not whether God’s glory sinks or swims. (Three Ser-
mons, p. 62.) That they hate God, because God crosses them in his laws. (Ibid. p. 38. c.)
These are the men, which Mr. W. supposes must, and may (some of them) truly profess a
subjection to Christ with all their hearts, and to be devoted to Christ; and the men that Mr.
S. taught, might covenant with God with their whole hearts, and give up all their hearts and
lives to Christ. Mr. Stoddard taught, that men that have but common grace, go quite in an-
other path than that which God directs to—That they set themselves against the way of
salvation God prescribes. (Safety, p. 10.) That man in his natural state is an enemy to the
way of salvation ; that he is an enemy to the law of God, and the gospel of Jesus Christ. (Ibid.
p. 106. b. c.) But yet these, if we believe Mr. W. may truly profess a subjection to Christ with
all their hearts, and give up themselves to him, to be taught, ruled, and led by him in a gospel-
way of salvation. Yet if we believe him, we must have the trouble of disbelieving him again;
for in these things he is as inconsistent with himself, as he is with Mr. S. For in his sermon
on Isa. xlv. 11. (p. 26, 27.) he says to those whose natures are unrenewed and unsanctified,
“If you are without Christ, you are in a state of slavery to sin, led about of divers lusts, and
under the reigning power and dominion of your corruptions, which debase your souls, and
bring them down from the dignity of their nature, to the vilest, most shameful, and accursed
bondage. And by means of sin, ye are in bondage to the devil, the most hateful and accursed
enemy of God and your own souls; 405 —and are opposing all the means of your own deliv-
erance. The offers of grace, the calls and invitations of the gospel, have all been ineffectual
to persuade you to accept of deliverance from a slavery you are willingly held in. Nay, you
strive against the liberty of the sons of God.” And yet some of these are (if we believe what
Mr. W. now says) subject to Christ with all their hearts, give up all their hearts and lives to
Christ, and give up themselves to be taught, ruled, and led by him in a gospel-way to salva-
tion.—Mr. W. in his sermons on Christ a King and Witness, (p. 81.) under a use of examin-
ation, giving marks of trial, says, “Have you unreservedly given up your souls and bodies
to him? [viz. Christ.] You must be all Christ’s, and have no other master. You must be given
to him without reserve, both in body and spirit, which are his.” But now it seems, these are
no discriminating evidences of true piety: he says, (Ibid. p. 118) “A man naturally hates God
should reign. And (p. 119. c.) speaking of the natural man, he says, “He hates to be controlled,
and in all things subjected to God;—he really owns no God but himself.” But if so, then
certainly he is not subject to God with all his heart.
405 And yet now it seems, some such do serve but one master, and give up themselves to Christ to be led by
him.
1939
SECTION V. Mr. W. inconsistent with Mr. Stoddard.